Secret remedies : $b What they cost and what they containBritish Medical Association
Science
Secret remedies : $b What they cost and what they contain
British Medical Association
Patent medicines
The analyses here given of some of the proprietary articles which the
public are induced to buy for the cure of ordinary colds and catarrh
furnish a good example of the absurdity of the barefaced pretensions
in which nostrum mongers indulge, for minor ailments are by no means
neglected by the makers of nostrums; if the price to be obtained is
somewhat lower than in the case of more serious disorders the cost
price can be reduced in an equal or greater proportion. Alarming
accounts, too, of the evils to be expected if resort be not had to the
advertised articles are not wanting. Thus, in the advertisement of one
of the articles described below, it is stated that catarrh “invariably
creates biliousness, constipation, pleurisy, asthma, bronchitis,
catarrhal fever, and consumption”; also that “it is estimated that
over 20,000 people died in the United Kingdom last year of consumption
caused by catarrh.” The remedy put forward for this malignant disease
is shown by analysis to consist of a solution of a pinch of common salt
with a trace of carbolic acid, the actual cost of the quantity sold for
a shilling being one-thirtieth part of a farthing. The probability that
many people would regard a slight cold in the head as not requiring a
resort to a “specialist in chronic disease in every form” such as the
proprietor of this preparation, is turned to account by a disparaging
reference to the medical profession. “Catarrh,” we are told, “in its
chronic form (and the complaints arising from it) is a malady which has
not, up to the present time, received that attention and research from
the medical faculty which it deserves. Most practitioners have given
it merely a passing thought, or poohed at it as a mere cold which
would soon pass off, and perhaps give some light tonic to tone up the
stomach.” Another of the “remedies” described well illustrates the way
in which the public is deluded by such “specialists”; camphor, quinine
and ipecacuanha are frequently employed as domestic remedies in the
early stages of a cold in the head, and persons who believe in their
usefulness can no doubt be induced to buy a “cold cure” which professes
to contain them in combination with other drugs, presented in a form
convenient and agreeable to be taken; but in the tablets which are
represented as consisting of cascara, bromide, quinine, ipecacuanha,
camphor and bryonia, analysis did not reveal any appreciable traces
of cascara, bromide, quinine, ipecacuanha, or camphor. The principal
ingredients actually present were cinchonine, an alkaloid found in
the bark from which quinine is prepared but cheaper than quinine, and
acetanilide, a chemical better known under the name antifebrin, both in
very small doses.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account