In English Josephus is best known through the translation of William
Whiston, first published nearly two centuries ago (1736). A revision of
Whiston was produced by the Rev. A. R. Shilleto in Bohn’s Standard
Library, with brief topographical notes by Sir C. W. Wilson (5 vols.,
London, G. Bell, 1889-1890). The revised Whiston is the most serviceable
rendering of the complete works available. Whiston has many merits, but
he had not access to a good text, his rendering is often at fault and he
had little regard for style; while Shilleto’s revision, which appeared
inopportunely just before the two modern editions of the Greek text,
unfortunately leaves much to be desired.
Of a very different character is the admirable translation of the
_Jewish War_ and the _Life_ made by the Rev. Dr. R. Traill and edited,
after his death, with notes by Isaac Taylor (London, 1862). Dr. Traill
fell a victim to his exertions in relieving his parishioners during the
Irish famine of 1846-7, and the version which he contemplated of the
remaining works never appeared. In his translation, which combines
faithfulness to the original with a fastidious regard for English style,
Traill went far towards accomplishing for Josephus what Jowett did for
Thucydides.
My procedure in the following selections has been first to produce a
version of my own, and then carefully to revise it with the help of both
Shilleto’s, Whiston and Traill. In several instances I had the
satisfaction of finding that my rendering practically agreed with
Traill’s, but I have not scrupled elsewhere to avail myself of happy
turns of expression where, as often, he had the advantage of me.
Josephus, with his feeling for good style and the pains which he took to
acquire it, deserves and demands much care in translation. While in
parts of his work his Greek is simple and easy, passages, on the other
hand, where he gives his reflections on the character, or estimates the
motives, of his _dramatis personæ_,[63] in the involved manner of
Thucydides, are extraordinarily difficult both to understand and to
reproduce in readable English.
I have selected the passages most relevant to Christian origins and New
Testament study, neglecting almost entirely the first twelve books of
the _Antiquities_.
For further literature reference may be made to the articles in the
_Dictionary of Christian Biography_ (Edersheim), the _Jewish
Encyclopædia_ (S. Krauss), Hastings’ _Dictionary of the Apostolic
Church_ (von Dobschütz), Hastings’ _Bible Dictionary_, Extra Volume
(Thackeray), and to Schürer’s _Jewish People in the time of Christ_
(E.T.), div. i. vol. i. pp. 77-110.
I have to acknowledge my gratitude to my sister-in-law, Miss Harriette
G. Orr, for her kind assistance in the compilation of the Index.
_July 1919._
Footnote 1:
Dated variously as A.D. 30 (Harnack), 33 (Ramsay), 34 (Lightfoot), and
35-6 (C. H. Turner, Hastings’ _D.B._, art. “Chronology”).
Footnote 2:
§§ (1) and (2).
Footnote 3:
§ (54).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account