Sex variant women in literature : $b A historical and quantitative surveyFoster, Jeannette H. (Jeannette Howard)
General
Sex variant women in literature : $b A historical and quantitative survey
Foster, Jeannette H. (Jeannette Howard)
Lesbians in literature; Sex in literature; Women in literature
It is not until reaching the final poem, “Envoi,” that the poet
indicates that anything has actually occurred outside of her haunted
imagination.
The catkin from the hazel swung
When you and I and March were young ...
The harvest moon rose round and red
When habit came and wonder fled ...
Snow lay on hedgerows of December
Then, when we could no more remember.
But the green flush was on the larch
When other loves we found in March.[68]
Here, for a moment, is the flavor of Millay, but not the intensity, and
to give evidence that the whole volume breathes subjective passion one
would need to quote it entirely, which is scarcely practicable. The most
vivid of the poems is also one of the best known:
Cygnet and barnacle goose
Follow her when she passes
Barefoot through daisied grasses.
Briars blown straying and loose
Catch at her as she goes
Down the path between woodbine and rose.
Seeking to follow and hold her,
The silly birds and the thorn.
But her laughter is merry with scorn.
What would she say if I told her
That the goose, and the swan,
And the thorn, and my spirit, were one?[69]
A negative note, barely audible, is sounded in the _Scrapbook_ of
Katherine Mansfield, published by her husband, Middleton Murry, in 1940,
a dozen years after her death. The poem is dated 1919, and entitled
“Friendship.”
When we were charming Backfisch
With curls and velvet bows
We shared a charming kitten
With tiny velvet toes.
It was so gay and playful;
It flew like a woolly ball
From my lap to your shoulder—
And oh, it was so small,
So warm and so obedient,
If we cried: “That’s enough!”
It lay and slept between us,
A purring ball of fluff.
But now that I am thirty
And she is thirty-one,
I shudder to discover
How wild our cat has run.
It’s bigger than a tiger,
Its eyes are jets of flame,
Its claws are gleaming daggers;
Could it have once been tame?
Take it away; I’m frightened!
But she, with placid brow,
Cries: “This is our Kitty-witty!
Why don’t you love her now?”[70]
Obviously Mansfield, unlike Millay, did not see perfection in the
fulfillment of variant love. Or at least not in this particular
fulfillment. Passages scattered through the _Scrapbook_ and the more
reticent _Journal_ (1928) reveal a compulsive and abject devotion in the
lifelong friend alluded to in the poem above. (See, for example,
“Toothache Sunday” in the _Scrapbook_.) The intensity of her friend’s
emotion troubled Mansfield, who sometimes felt herself “a callous brute”
to be unable to return it in kind or to make its possessor happy. “I
don’t know why I always shrink ever so faintly from her touch. I could
not kiss her lips.”[71] But, however innocent of expression, the
relationship was a problem she could never discuss with her husband, and
she felt that it cast a permanent, if faint, shadow between her and “J.”
(Murry).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account