Sex variant women in literature : $b A historical and quantitative surveyFoster, Jeannette H. (Jeannette Howard)
General
Sex variant women in literature : $b A historical and quantitative survey
Foster, Jeannette H. (Jeannette Howard)
Lesbians in literature; Sex in literature; Women in literature
Interest in female variance was, however, already alive when
Hirschfeld’s efforts in 1896 began to encourage its literary expression,
as evidenced by the sudden outburst of fiction as well as poetry during
the following decade. In 1897, Gabriele Reuter, a writer of ability,
published a novel of autobiographical pattern, _Aus guter Familie_,[2]
which included among its heroine’s early experiences a variant, possibly
lesbian, attachment—the _Jahrbuch’s_ note does not specify. In 1900
Elisabeth Dauthendey produced _Vom neuen Weib und seiner
Sittlichkeit_,[3] semi-narrative sketches like Colette’s in _Ces
Plaisirs_. The “New Woman’s” ideal is a life of quiet intimacy with
other women, free of the “brutal” relations with men which dull
appreciation of more delicate emotional nuances. An interlude with a
tribade, a ‘confident, wise, almost manly’ individual, at first promises
fulfillment of all the writer’s hopes. But a few amorous nights force
her to recognize that, like a man, this woman cannot distinguish between
crude sex and love. In the same year von Seydlitz used a case history
from the 1840s—possibly from the same source as Kaspar’s _Klinische
Novellen_—as the basis for _Pierre’s Ehe: Psychologische Probleme_.[4]
Its hero is unfortunate enough to love an odd, hard, masculine girl who
finally succumbs to his persistence, but is unable to cooperate
sexually, and presently the partners find themselves in love with the
same woman. In the course of a jealous brawl Pierre believes he has
killed his wife; he makes a successful escape into the merchant marine
and dies in Saigon without learning that he is innocent of manslaughter.
The wife, now a confirmed transvestist, lives out her life as a valet
without further emotional complication.
In 1900 also, Alfred Meebold included a tragic variant novelette, “Dr.
Erna Redens Thorheit und Erkenntnis,”[5] in the volume _Allerhand Volk_.
The larger portion of the tale presents Dr. Erna’s unhappy heterosexual
affair with a fellow medical student. To recover from her consequent
depression she travels in Italy with an artist, Lucie, who has been her
particularly warm and eager confidante. The latter is a homosexual, but
she manages to conceal the nature of her feelings until the two meet
another woman, an artist long acquainted with Lucie. In the course of a
quarrel this woman reveals Lucie’s secret. Although Dr. Erna has now
recovered from her heterosexual disappointment and exhibits a
sympathetic understanding of Lucie’s emotion, she is unable to return it
in kind, and in despondency Lucie kills herself. Dr. Erna then returns
to Germany full of crusading zeal against those who persecute
homosexuals. This bears slight but sufficient resemblance to Borys’s
later _Carlotta Noll_ in French to suggest that both may have been based
on a single known episode, or that the one influenced the other. The
German version, be it noted, is by far the more sympathetic.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account