Mr. Shaw’s sole contribution to our knowledge of Shakespeare is the
coupling of him with Dickens, which is very much the same thing as if
one tried to explain Titian by coupling him with Hogarth. This, in my
opinion, is Mr. Shaw’s only original observation on the subject, and its
perfect originality I should be the last to deny.
I have not yet read or seen Mr. Shaw’s play: I only wish here to draw
attention to the fact that he has already annexed a good deal of my work
and put it forth as his own, giving me only the most casual and grudging
mention. From the larger acknowledgment in _The Observer_, I naturally
infer that in this new play he has taken from me even more than he could
hope to pass off as his own.
All this in the England of to-day is looked upon as honourable and
customary. If Mr. Shaw can annex my work it only shows that he is
stronger than I am or abler, and this fact in itself would be generally
held to absolve and justify him: _vae victis_ is the noble English motto
in such cases. But if it turns out in the long struggle that Mr. Shaw is
only more successful for the moment than I am, if my books and writings
on Shakespeare have come to stay, then I can safely leave the task of
judging Mr. Shaw to the future.
In any case I can console myself. It amused me years ago to see Mr. Shaw
using scraps of my garments to cover his nakedness; he now struts about
wearing my livery unashamed. I am delighted that so little of it makes
him a complete suit. My wardrobe is still growing in spite of his
predatory instincts, and he is welcome to as much of it as I have cast
off and he can cut to fit.
But is this the best that Mr. Shaw can do with his astonishing quickness
and his admirable gift of lucid, vigorous speech? Will he, who is not
poor, always be under our tables for the crumbs? Why should he not share
the feast, or, better still, make a feast of his own? Why does he not
take himself in hand, and crush the virtue out of himself and distil it
into some noble draught? The quintessence of Shaw would be worth having.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account