Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
As we have mentioned, this rationalisation is no unusual phenomenon
in ordinary life. It will be clear to anyone who gives the question
a moment’s thought that few of the non-scientific[17] beliefs held
by even a highly educated person have ever been logically reasoned
out from fundamental principles. In fact such principles frequently
cannot be reached, for the very good reason that they have never been
consciously conceived by the individual. One’s views on religion,
politics, or the relations and rights of the sexes may exhibit in their
outer casings a semblance of rational structure: their core, however,
is not reason but emotion. As James expresses it:—
“In its inner nature, belief or the sense of reality is a sort of
feeling more allied to the emotions than to anything else ... reality
means simply relation to our emotional and active life. This is the
only sense which the word ever has in the mouths of practical men....
Whenever an object so appeals to us that we turn to it, accept it,
fill our mind with it, or practically take account of it, so far it is
real for us and we believe it. Whenever, on the contrary, we ignore
it, fail to consider it or act upon it, despise it, reject it, forget
it, so far it is unreal for us and is disbelieved.... Whatever things
have intimate and continuous connection with my life are things whose
reality I cannot doubt.”[18]
Few people, however, realise this truth so clearly, or express it so
lucidly, as Professor James. Often we believe that we are logically
convinced when in reality we have been convinced first, and have
invented reasons for our conviction afterwards. But many of our beliefs
and attitudes have been implanted in us in childhood or early youth
by processes which could not by the wildest stretch of imagination be
called logical. And not the least important of those beliefs are those
held by the average Briton with regard to insanity.[19]
For the patient, then, his mental troubles, having intimate and
continuous connection with his life, become very real indeed. But the
longer he is left alone to “cheer up,” the longer he broods over his
troubles in isolation, the longer he is allowed to build theories
upon his inadequate and inaccurate data, the more intimately and
continuously connected with his life will the abnormalities become.
They may come to be so integrated with each other that his very
personality becomes tinged. Then he is no longer a normal person
battling with his separate enemies, but one who has made terms, and
those often disastrous ones, with his closely allied foes. An attempt
to cure him at this stage will then necessitate the analysis of a
highly complex compound, while in the early and middle stages merely
the attack upon separated elements is necessary.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account