Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
In some instances, however, just as in the civil cases, the boredom of
isolation may produce the good effects noted above. But there is the
corresponding disadvantage that if you isolate a man and put a special
nurse to look after him it is impossible to convince him that his case
is not serious. It may, indeed, help him to persuade himself that he
is really going insane. As a matter of experience, it is found that
very many men cannot stand isolation for long; they feel that they
must break out, even if they realise that punishment is certain for
doing so. The conversation of patients who are undergoing treatment
by isolation is often perfectly frank about it. They tell the medical
officer they will break out at the first opportunity; that the few
hours of freedom would more than compensate for the punishment which
would come afterwards. Again, it must be apparent that, when the
trouble is due in any considerable measure to the re-awakening of
emotions linked up with some painful earlier experience, isolation
is not likely to be effective in many cases, and may be definitely
harmful. Neither should it be forgotten that such measures fail to
isolate the patient from his worst enemy, himself.
Even in those cases in which it is useful, isolation, if unduly
prolonged, may spoil its own good effects. It may so accustom the
patient to a solitary mode of existence that the presence of other
persons may make him irritable when at the end of his time of seclusion
he is compelled to associate with his fellows.
There is another fact which has to be taken into consideration—and
this applies especially in civil practice, where the patient or his
family have to pay for the treatment. We refer to the expensiveness
of treatment by isolation. Unless it can be shown that it is the
best or the only hopeful method to adopt, the physician must feel
some hesitancy in the majority of cases, in prescribing such costly
measures.[29]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account