Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
From the completely different nature of the circumstances of the
nerve-stricken soldier and civilian respectively it is clear that
such total isolation can be considered necessary for soldiers only in
very few cases, even though the modified forms of isolation, to which
reference has been made, may be useful for most of such patients. The
important point that emerges from this discussion is the necessity
which is laid upon the physician of determining, in the case of each
individual patient, whether isolation of any kind is desirable, what
form it should take, and especially when it should be used, modified or
discontinued.
_Suggestion and Hypnosis._ We have already touched briefly on the
need for sympathetic firmness and for inspiring the patient with
confidence that he will recover. But such firmness can be useful only
when it is supported by respect for and confidence in the physician.
In most cases such respect can be gained only by acquiring a real
insight into the patient’s condition and by treating him tactfully and
reasonably. It is too often forgotten that the neurasthenic patient’s
continual and intense criticism of himself makes him especially quick
at intuitively becoming conscious of the physician’s failings. Under
such circumstances, if the doctor does not secure the patient’s respect
and convince him that he really understands his condition, the former’s
firmness and confident assurances will avail him nothing: he has
shown his hand; his failure will excite contempt; and the patient’s
intractable, _enlightened_ stubbornness will be fatal to any further
hope of influence on the part of that particular physician.
Ever since mankind first sought help from his fellows for his
afflictions of body or mind, confidence in the efficiency of the
adviser’s ability has been an essential factor in leech-craft. To be
able to convince a patient that he is going to recover and that medical
advice will help towards that end is certainly not the least of the
physician’s qualifications. But unless the assurances given him are
based upon real insight and understanding, the process of securing the
patient’s confidence is not very different from the charlatan’s blatant
boasting. In other words, it is analogous to the confidence trick.
The confidence which is inspired in the patient by his conviction of
the physician’s real understanding of his condition is an altogether
different matter. Such “suggestion” necessarily enters into all
successful treatment and this applies in a very special manner to the
cure of mental ailments.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account