Traumatic neuroses; War neuroses; World War, 1914-1918 -- Health aspects; World War, 1914-1918 -- Veterans -- Mental health
With reference to the dictum “Once a lunatic always a lunatic” we
should like to call attention to another statement in this report. “The
fact that, _even under the present conditions of delayed treatment,
about 33 per cent. of those admitted to the asylums of England and
Wales are discharged recovered_, demonstrates that the feelings of
helplessness and hopelessness, with which such illnesses are usually
regarded, are by no means justified. The evidence of many authorities
who have had practical experience of the value of treatment during
the incipient stages of the illness, shows conclusively that the
exercise of scientific care during the early phases of mental disorder
would save many from such a complete breakdown as would necessitate
certification and removal to an asylum. In all other branches of
medicine facilities for dealing with disease in its initial stages are
recognised as indispensable and therefore the Committee regard it as
essential that, in the large centres of population at any rate, means
should be provided to obviate the delay that now exists in providing
adequate treatment for mental disorders. It is, therefore, recommended
that psychiatric clinics should be established.”[80]
Again, at the International Congress of Medicine in London, in August,
1913, an important discussion of these problems was introduced by
an account of the Henry Phipps Psychiatric Clinic which has been
established in Baltimore for the treatment of mental disorders, and
for teaching and research in this subject. In the course of the
discussion special emphasis was laid upon “the necessity for _teaching
the medical profession and the public_ that many mental disorders are
absolutely recoverable, that good hospital and scientific treatment
save many, that the mere economy of our monster institutions represents
a sham economy paid for by the patients and their families, and that
psychiatry must extend beyond the asylums.”[81]
Emphasis was also laid upon the importance of making these hospitals,
for the care and cure of those suffering from mental illness, centres
for scientific education and research and for the development of
prophylactic measures. For, unless medical students are provided with
facilities for the study of these early cases the present deplorable
condition of affairs will be perpetuated. All honest medical work is
essentially research; for every individual patient presents problems
which need investigation; and facilities should be provided for making
such enquiries under the most favourable conditions. As Dr. Flexner has
well said,[82] it is impossible “to develop two types of physician,
one to find things out, the other to apply what has been ascertained.
For the same kind of intelligence, the same sorts of observation,
knowledge and reasoning power are needed for the application as for the
discovery of effective therapeutic procedure.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account