Alma-Tadema, Lawrence, 1836-1912 -- Criticism and interpretation
The elder classical painters thought to render their work more truly
classical by placing their protagonists in large empty monumental
spaces, just as Corneille and Racine thought to give the true
classical ring to their plays when they removed them from every-day
emotions, and rolled out high-sounding and rhetorical phrases. Alma
Tadema, instead, is convinced that these dead-and-gone folk were in
all fundamental essentials like to ourselves, that they lived, loved,
joked and chattered just as we do, and this conviction has found
expression in his pictures that deal less and less with the graver,
grander moments of their existence, and more with the petty intimate
details of their home life. His pictures might almost be said to be
a series of instantaneous reproductions of the life of the Roman
patricians. The plebs have no interest for him, they rarely figure
in his canvases, and when they do their figures are entirely
subordinate. The Roman of Alma Tadema's pictures abides in a world
of idle luxury, in which nothing matters much unless it ministers to
sensuous enjoyment. It is the outward seeming of life and objects
that attracts him, their inner deeper meaning matters to him as
little as their subject. The life aim of his men and women seems to
be to exist happily and placidly, untroubled by material cares or
disturbing emotions.
In his method of composing his pictures Alma Tadema's manner is also
the absolute antithesis of what is commonly regarded as the classic
method. So far is he from putting his principal personages well into
the middle of his canvas, from following a pyramidal arrangement,
that in his effort to be natural and unconventional, he even at times
commits extravagances in order to escape from the beaten path, as,
for example, in his portrait of Dr. Epps, in which there are shown
one head and a bust, no arms, but three hands, the third being that
of the unseen patient whose pulse the physician is supposed to feel.
This is an extreme instance, but a tendency to dismember his figures,
to show us only half a figure, a detached head, a hand without a
body, a foot without a visible leg, occurs every now and again, and
not certainly to the detriment of a realistic effect, but most
certainly to the detriment of composition as classically understood.
This tendency, no doubt, results from his love of Japanese art, an
art that has had a visible influence upon his methods of disposing
his composition. Indeed, it might almost be said that Alma Tadema
does not compose his pictures at all. He certainly does not do so
according to the ordinary acceptance of the term in art, he rather
disposes his personages about his canvas, apparently at hazard, much
as they might group themselves in real life. But under this seeming
negligence, is hidden great care, immense painstaking, a striving to
give to his pictures their maximum of expressive force, for in Alma
Tadema's work, everything as well as every person, has its suggestive
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account