Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulityDavenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
History
Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulity
Davenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
Common fallacies; Impostors and imposture
Evemerus, a Messenian, or, according to some writers, a Sicilian, a
cotemporary of Cassander, king of Macedon, seems to have been the
first who attempted this kind of fraud; for he pretended to have found
on a golden column, in an ancient temple in the island of Panchæa, a
genealogical account of a family that had once reigned there, in which
were comprised the principal deities then worshipped by the Greeks.
Not only were their lives recorded, but also their deaths; and thus a
deadly blow was aimed at their divinity. This fable was translated into
Latin by Ennius.
Annius of Viterbo, who was born at Viterbo, in 1432, and whose real
name was John Nanni, has been charged with framing inscriptions from
his own imagination, and burying them in certain places, that, when
they had acquired an appearance of antiquity, he might pretend to
find, and might vend them. He is also said to have manufactured medals
of an early date. Both these charges are, however, erroneous. It is
nevertheless certain that, accompanied by his own commentaries, he
presented to the world, as genuine, the pretended works of several
exceedingly ancient authors; for this he has incurred much odium, but
it is believed, by many learned men, that, instead of being a forger,
he was himself deceived by forged manuscripts. This fraud gave rise to
a violent controversy, in which many of the most eminent literary men
were engaged.
The great uncertainty relative to the genuineness of inscriptions on
ancient statues originated in the ignorance or fraud of those who
restored them. Even Phædrus, in the application of a fable at the
beginning of his fifth book, alludes to this practice in his time by
mercenary artists. “The name of Apollodorus, on the plinth of the
Venus de Medicis,” says Mr. Dallaway, “has been detected as a modern
forgery. The statues which have been dug up in a mutilated state, and
placed in the hands of venal or ignorant artists, have always had the
name of some eminent character given to them. Doubts of genuineness are
at least allowable, and often justified, of those statues the hands of
which have been evidently engrafted.”
The fabrication of spurious coins for the market was neither a modern
contrivance nor of unfrequent occurrence. The collection of medals
belonging to Dr. Hunter affords some examples. One of a leaden coin,
cased in silver, as remote as the time of Selcucus, king of Syria, may
be seen in that cabinet; and also a similar coin of the city of Naples.
In the Roman series, Neumann makes mention of a remarkable instance
from Schulzius, of a leaden coin of Nero, which had been anciently
circulated for brass, in which metal it was enclosed. In Dr. Hunter’s
cabinet are two examples of leaden coins covered with gold; one of the
Emperor Trajan, the other of his successor.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account