Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulityDavenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
History
Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulity
Davenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
Common fallacies; Impostors and imposture
Demosthenes relates, on the authority of Solon, that several cities
in Greece adulterated their coins; and Dion Cassius states, that the
Emperor Caracalla, instead of gold and silver, issued brass and leaden
coins, which were merely washed or cased with silver or gold, to
conceal the fraud.
Evelyn, in his “Numismata,” exposes many of the tricks of those who, at
the period at which he wrote, supplied the market with spurious coins
and medals. “The most likely means,” says he, “for procuring genuine
coins or medals, are from country people, who plough and dig about
old walls, mounds, &c., where castrametations have formerly been. The
composition or grouping of the figures should also be well considered,
that it be with judgment; for the ancients seldom crowded many figures
together. A perfect medal has its profile and out-strokes sharp, and
by no means rugged; the figures clean and well polished, and an almost
inimitable spirit of antiquity and excellence, in the most ancient.
Yet after much research, travel and diligence, cost and caution, one
is perpetually in danger of being deceived, and imposed upon, by
cheaters and mercenary forgers; and even the country people, in Italy
and Holland, often deceive the less wary medalist. Where a series of
ancient medals is known to be imperfect, suspicion should always attach
to him who pretends to supply the chasm, and complete the series.[14]
“All medals of gold, Greek or Roman, that are not of the best alloy,
are to be considered impostures.
“The manufacturers of pseudo-antiques, will raise and carve the
effigies of one emperor out of another antique head of a less costly
and rare description; for instance, an Otho out of a Nero; and also
the reverses: nay, they have the address to slit and divide two
several medals, and, with a certain tenacious cement, join the reverse
of one to the head of the other, and so repair and trim the edges
that it is impossible to discover the ingenious fraud. A partial
deceit is often practised on the unwary, by taking off a part of a
relievo, and applying it to another medal; by the same artifice and
dexterity, the title of a genuine medal may be entirely altered, where
there are but few letters, by pinching up a letter in one part, or
removing superfluous matter in another, so that in process of time the
metamorphosis is complete.”
Mr. Obadiah Walker accuses the Jews of being most industrious in
putting off spurious medals. Some persons purposely bury medals
near the remains of some Roman works, and then pretend to have
found them by chance; as is also reported of a certain statuary, who
carved the pseudo Hercules, and sold it at a great price, before the
justly-admired original statue was discovered.
Rival collectors have been known to prey on each other’s rarities, by
clandestinely swallowing the most precious gem in a collection; at
least an anecdote to this effect is related on the continent, of Baron
Storch, a celebrated gem collector.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account