Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulityDavenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
History
Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulity
Davenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
Common fallacies; Impostors and imposture
By directly attacking the imagination did Mr. Loutherbourg cure
vast numbers of patients. He became impressed with the idea that he
had a commission from above to cure diseases, and his door was soon
crowded with patients all day. Amongst others, a respectable man,
from the country, had been afflicted with great pains and swellings,
particularly about the loins, so that he could not walk across the
room. On entering, Mr. Loutherbourg looked steadfastly at him, and
said, “I know your complaint, sir, look at me.” They continued looking
at each other some minutes; then Mr. L. asked, if he did not feel
some warmth at his loins. The man replied that he did. “Then you will
feel in a few minutes much greater warmth.” After a short pause, the
man said, “I feel as if a person was pouring boiling water upon me.”
Still looking him in the face, Mr. L. said, “How did you come here,
sir?” “In a coach.” “Then go and discharge your coach, and walk back to
town” (from Hammersmith Terrace, where Mr. L. resided). The coach was
discharged, and the patient walked to town, and next day he walked five
hours about town without fatigue. He offered ten pounds; but Mr. L.
would not take a farthing.
The easy manner in which people have become a prey to illiterate and
dangerous pretenders, in the medical art, has been long known. Many
thousand volumes would attest the truth of this observation, which has
been often repeated. Cotta, in 1612, says, “There is no place or person
ignorant how all sorts of vile people and unskilful persons, without
restraint, make gainful traffic by botching in physic; and hereby
numbers of unwotting innocents daily enthrall and betray themselves to
sustain the riot of their enemies and common _homicides_.” The late Dr.
Buchan exclaimed, “As matters stand at present it is easier to cheat a
man out of his life than a shilling, and almost impossible to detect or
punish the offender.” The case is still the same.
Uroscopy, or water-casting, was once very much practised, and those
who professed to cure diseases by such inspection, simply, were
consulted by all classes of persons. The absurdity of these pretensions
was forcibly exposed by Dr. Radcliffe, on the following occasion. A
shoemaker’s wife applied to him to relieve her husband, who was very
ill, presenting him with a phial of his water for inspection. The
doctor exchanged the contents, and bade her take that back, and tell
her husband to make a pair of shoes, by the same instructions.
A Dr. Meyersbach started, about 1770, as a water doctor; he had
arrived from Germany in a starving state, and was first an ostler at a
riding-school. Not making money fast enough, he set up as a doctor, and
was consulted by all classes. Dr. Lettsom took great pains to expose
the ignorance and knavery of Meyersbach, whose violent medicines, if
they sometimes cured, more often aggravated, his patients’ sufferings.
It is believed that he acquired a good fortune, with which he retired
to his native country.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account