Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulityDavenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
History
Sketches of imposture, deception, and credulity
Davenport, R. A. (Richard Alfred)
Common fallacies; Impostors and imposture
One unprincipled wretch, in an hospital, pretending to be afflicted
with a hopeless complaint, which was a subject of offence to the whole
ward, being detected, it was determined to apply the actual cautery.
On the first application of the red-hot spatula, this fellow, who for
eleven months had lost the use of his lower limbs, gave the man who
held his leg so violent a kick, that he threw him down, and instantly
exclaimed that he was shamming, and would do his duty if released; but
the surgeon declared that he would apply the iron to the other hip, on
which he roared out that he had been shamming to get his discharge. To
the amusement of all around, he walked to his bed; and when the burned
parts were healed, he returned to his duty.
Spitting of blood and consumption are rather favourite diseases with
soldiers who seek their discharge from the service through imposture;
yet an acute physician may easily detect the imposition. Palpitation
and violent action of the heart the impostors know how to produce by
the juice of hellebore; vomiting by secret pressure on the stomach;
tympany, or distention of the body by air, is produced by swallowing,
on philosophical and chemical principles, chalk and vinegar.
The acute diseases have many symptoms which are easily simulated, but
as easily detected. The appearance of the white tongue is created
by rubbing it with chalk, or whitening from the wall; but washing
the mouth with water at once proves the deceit. Dr. Hennen, in his
Military Surgery, says, “Profligates have, to my knowledge, boasted
that they have often received indulgences from the medical officers
in consequence of a supposed febrile attack, by presenting themselves
after a night’s debauch, which they had purposely protracted, to
aid the deception. Febrile symptoms are also produced by swallowing
tobacco-juice. One man, if unwilling to be cured secundum artem, was at
least anxious to enumerate his symptoms in an orthodox manner, for he
had purloined some pages from Zimmerman’s Treatise on Dysentery, (the
disease he had thought proper to simulate,) from one of the medical
officers; and from which he was daily in the habit of recounting a
change of symptoms. Stoical indifference to their frequently painful
imposture and hardihood in maintaining its character, are the necessary
qualifications of malingerers, who have frequently evinced a constancy
and fortitude under severe pain and privations worthy of a better
cause.”
A patient permitted all the preparatory measures for amputation before
he thought proper to relax his knee-joint; and another suffered himself
to be almost drowned in a deep lake, into which he was plunged from a
boat, before he stretched out his arm to save himself by swimming, an
exercise in which he was known to excel.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account