Slavery -- United States; United States -- Politics and government -- 1849-1853
1. Let me first refer to a misrepresentation by Mr. Webster of a plain
matter of fact. In professing to quote, from his 7th of March speech,
a passage on which I had made a criticism, he alters the passage so
as to evade the criticism, and then condemns me for making it. The
original passage in his speech read as follows: “I would not take pains
to reäffirm an ordinance of Nature, nor to reënact the will of God.”
This was the sentiment I criticized. It appears in these words in the
_National Intelligencer_, in the _Washington Union_, in the _Republic_,
in the _Globe_, and in the pamphlet edition of his speech, which he
dedicated to the people of Massachusetts. But in the Kennebec letter,
in order to elude the point of my criticism, he has interpolated a
word into the sentence, which changes its whole meaning. Affirming
that he quotes himself, he says, “I would not take pains USELESSLY to
reäffirm an ordinance of Nature, or to reënact the will of God.” By
foisting in the word which I have underscored, he changes the entire
character of the sentiment advanced. As now stated, nobody can dissent
from it; for who would announce, in a distinct proposition, that he
would _uselessly_ do any thing? But, as originally stated, nobody can
assent to it. This alteration of his language, after my criticism upon
it was made, is not only unjust towards me, but it contains a latent
confession that he knew he was wrong, but thought this surreptitious
changing of his doctrine to be a less evil than a frank acknowledgment
of his error. Had he truly quoted the original false sentiment, the
world would have seen that I was right; but, in his dilemma, he falsely
interpolated a true sentiment, not only to evade the force of my
criticism upon him, but to make occasion for an unfounded imputation
against me.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account