Social devices for impelling women to bear and rear childrenHollingworth, Leta Stetter
General
Social devices for impelling women to bear and rear children
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Child rearing; Fertility, Human; Public opinion; Social control; Women -- Social conditions
_Art._—A very long paper might be written to describe the various uses
to which art has been put in holding up the ideal of motherhood. The
mother, with children at her breast, is the favorite theme of artists.
The galleries of Europe are hung full of Madonnas of every age and
degree. Poetry abounds in allusions to the sacredness and charm of
motherhood, depicting the yearning of the adult for his mother’s knee.
Fiction is replete with happy and adoring mothers. Thousands of songs
are written and sung concerning the ideal relation which exists between
mother and child. In pursuing the mother-child theme through art one
would not be led to suspect that society finds it necessary to make laws
against contra-conception, infanticide, abortion, and infant desertion.
Art holds up to view only the compensations of motherhood, leaving the
other half of the theme in obscurity, and thus acting as a subtle ally
of population.
_Illusion._—This is the last of Ross’s categories to which I wish to
refer. Ross says:
In the taming of men there must be provided coil after coil to
entangle the unruly one. Mankind must use snares as well as
leading-strings, will-o-the-wisps as well as lanterns. The truth by
all means, if it will promote obedience, but in any case obedience! We
shall examine not creeds now, but the films, veils, hidden mirrors,
and half lights by which men are duped as to that which lies nearest
them, their own experience. This time we shall see men led captive,
not by dogmas concerning a world beyond experience, but by artfully
fostered misconceptions of the pains, satisfactions, and values lying
under their very noses.
One of the most effective ways of creating the desired illusion about
any matter is by concealing and tabooing the mention of all the painful
and disagreeable circumstances connected with it. Thus there is a very
stern social taboo on conversation about the processes of birth. The
utmost care is taken to conceal the agonies and risks of child-birth
from the young. Announcement is rarely made of the true cause of deaths
from child-birth. The statistics of maternal mortality have been
neglected by departments of health, and the few compilations which have
been made have not achieved any wide publicity or popular discussion.
Says Katharine Anthony, in her recent book on _Feminism in Germany and
Scandinavia_ (1915):
There is no evidence that the death rate of women from child-birth has
caused the governing classes many sleepless nights.
Anthony gives some statistics from Prussia (where the figures have been
calculated), showing that
between 1891 and 1900 11 per cent of the deaths of all women between
the ages of twenty-five and forty years occurred in child-birth....
During forty years of peace Germany lost 400,000 mothers’ lives, that
is, ten times what she lost in soldiers’ lives in the campaign of 1870
and 1871.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account