It is probably the usual effect of displacement to both intensify and
disorganize the processes of selection; there is a livelier conflict of
persons and tendencies along with a lack of established institutions to
preside over this conflict and regulate the outcome. The result, as
regards individuals, is likely to be a greater diversity in their
fortunes than could exist under more orderly conditions; opportunity, of
certain kinds at least, may be increased, and those who have capacities
suited to take advantage of it, or who happen to be in favorable
situations, will prosper; others, who might have done as well as any in
quieter times, will be crowded down. A chance mixture of characters and
temperaments, brought into contact with a chance mixture of conditions
and opportunities, will naturally produce many new combinations, both
fortunate and unfortunate.
The principle applies to moral as well as economic struggles. The
unregulated freedom of action, forcing constant choice and
self-reliance, develops the mind rapidly, one way or the other, and is
likely to produce some characters of great vigor and independence, while
others, not necessarily of inferior capacity, may suffer decay. Those
who come out successfully may not be the best but simply the toughest,
the least sensitive and vulnerable. Miss Addams writes: “A settlement
constantly sees the deterioration of highly educated foreigners under
the strain of maladjustment, in marked contrast to the often rapid rise
of the families of illiterate immigrants.”[40]
In the international migrations of our day, which in some years have
brought more than a million strangers to the harbors of the United
States, the guiding motives are mainly economic, and these also cause
the immigrants to congregate in certain localities after they arrive. It
is true that part of them come in families, and that people from the
same provinces and neighborhoods often settle together; but the social
displacement, along with the total change in environment and modes of
work, is sufficient to cause wide-spread maladjustment and strain. It
has been said, with much appearance of truth, that it would be easier
for the immigrants to fight Indians, like the first settlers, than to
combat the perplexing social and economic conditions of the present
time. There is, perhaps, no topic of the kind on which the evidence is
more profuse and unanimous than this of the moral strain and partial
degeneration of our foreign element. It would be easy to collect any
number of passages like the following, from a settlement report:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account