All this comparison and selection cannot be managed without a large
measure of competition, however it may be mitigated. It would seem that
there must always be an element of conflict in our relation with others,
as well as one of mutual aid; the whole plan of life calls for it; our
very physiognomy reflects it, and love and strife sit side by side upon
the brow of man. The forms of opposition change, but the amount of it,
if not constant, is at any rate subject to no general law of diminution.
If we are to make the process of life rational there is nothing which
more requires our attention than the adaptive organization of persons.
At present it is, for the most part, a matter of rather blind
experimentation, unequal, from the point of view of individuals, and
inefficient from that of society. The child does not know what his part
in life is, or how to find it out: he looks to us to show him. But
neither do we know: we say he must work it out for himself. Meanwhile
the problem is solved badly, in great part, and to the detriment of all
of us. Moreover, since it becomes daily more difficult with the growing
complexity and specialization of life, the unconscious methods upon
which we have hitherto relied are less and less adequate to meet it.
The method, however we may improve it, must remain experimental,
involving comparison and selection as well as co-operation. The only
possible alternative, and that only a partial one, would be a system of
caste under which the function of the son would be determined by that of
his father. If the social system were stationary, so that the functions
themselves did not change, this method would insure order without
conflict, after a fashion; but I need not say that it would be an
inefficient fashion and an order contrary to the spirit of modern life.
For us the way plainly lies through the acceptance of the selective
method, and its scientific study and reconstruction.
What the individual demands with reference to this reorganizing process
is opportunity; that is, such freedom of conditions that he may find his
natural place, that he may serve society in the way for which his native
capacity and inclination, properly trained and measured with those of
others in fair competition, will fit him. In so far as he can have this
he can realize himself best, and do most for the general good. It is the
desirable condition from both the personal and the public points of
view.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account