Social Work; Essays on the Meeting Ground of Doctor and Social Worker — John Shaqi
Social Work; Essays on the Meeting Ground of Doctor and Social WorkerCabot, Richard C. (Richard Clarke)
Science
Social Work; Essays on the Meeting Ground of Doctor and Social Worker
Cabot, Richard C. (Richard Clarke)
Charities, Medical; Friendly visiting; Medical social work -- United States; Social service
Confronted with people's troubles, whether physical or mental or
spiritual, we are tempted, and above all _they_ are tempted to regard
the sickness, the poverty, or the sorrow in the light of an emergency,
an accident, and therefore as something to be treated at once and by
means which have little to do with the past and the future. On the other
hand, the standpoint of science and philosophy, and of any one who has
labored long in the field of social work with or without science or
philosophy, is the point of view of history. This is the habit of mind
which makes us believe that a supposed "accident" belongs in a long
sequence, a long chain of events, so that it is impossible to understand
or to help it without knowledge, as extensive as our time and our wisdom
will allow, of that whole chain.
Consider a few examples which contrast these two points of view. When a
boy is brought into court for stealing, it is almost always his attempt,
and the attempt of those who defend him, to show that such a thing has
never happened in his life before; he "just _happened_ to steal." But as
we inquire more closely into the facts, we almost always find that this
is a fundamentally untrue statement of the case. For the offence which
brought him into court is almost never the first offence. He has always
stolen before. On the present occasion he was a member of a boy's gang;
it was not in the least accidental that he got into that group of boys.
As we search back in his history, and perhaps into his father's history,
we find reasons why he is what he is now. Again, we are trying to help
some wayward girl who has taken an immoral step. We are told what a
wholly unforeseeable _accident_ it was that got her into her trouble.
But if we can get a good picture of her past, we find that we could have
traced the tendency to weakness of this kind from the time she was born.
So it is in medical matters. _Emergencies are rare._ I remember being
called out of a sound sleep one night to go "as quickly as possible" to
see a man who had discovered a lump upon his breast bone. He was quite
sure that the swelling had appeared since the time when he went to bed.
It was then one o'clock in the morning, and he had gone to bed at
eleven. Well, I found a slight bony irregularity in his breast bone
which doubtless had been there about forty-five years, as he was
forty-six years old. He did not pretend that it hurt him, and did not
undertake to show that he was ill in any other way. But this lump had
come and naturally he wanted help at once.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account