Christian socialism; Owen, Robert, 1771-1858. Book of the new moral world; Socialism -- Great Britain
But, if man from his birth has an evil principle within him, (I would
call it a depraved nature,) then Mr. Owen’s principles, however much they
may modify and change the external character, will not avail in changing
the heart. His system will no more produce the results which he
promises, the paradise of joy which he pictures before his followers,
than have the systems of the old world. And, therefore, he is only
amusing and deluding those that attend to him with pleasing dreams which
can never be realized. If this, however, were all, it would not much
matter; he might be left to pursue his course undisturbed; but when it is
known that the effect of his system, whatever may be his design, is to
take off the mind from everything but what is connected with his earthly
paradise, and so cause it to neglect, and even despise everything
connected with eternity and everlasting life, and the happiness of the
principle which never dies, it would be, not only a dereliction of
principle, but also a want of love to one’s species, not to lift up the
voice against him, and endeavour to warn such persons of their fatal
error, and the destructive consequences which must, and will inevitably
ensue.
But another fundamental principle of Mr. Owen’s system, as expressed in
the 2nd and 3rd Fundamental Facts, and 13th Law, is, “Man is compelled by
his original constitution, to receive his feelings and his convictions
independently of his will;” and “his feelings, or his convictions, or
both of them united, create the motive to action called the will, which
stimulates him to act, and decides his actions;” and “each individual is
so organized that he must believe according to the strongest conviction
which is made upon his mind:” the plain meaning of which is, that man is
not accountable for his belief, neither ought he to be considered
accountable for his actions; and which, indeed, Mr. Owen does not leave
his readers to deduce from his principles, but which he himself
explicitly states. Thus, he says, “Man cannot be bad by nature, and it
must,” therefore, “be a gross error to make him responsible for what
nature and his predecessors have compelled him to be.” (Book of the New
Moral World, p. 54.)
That man is not accountable, that he can think as he likes, and act as he
pleases, without being amenable, either to God or man, for his thoughts
or his actions, is a doctrine which will well accord with the wishes of
all those who feel the idea of God and judgment a restraint upon their
conduct, and human laws oftentimes a barrier in the way of indulging
their evil desires. And it is lamentable to think how many, even of this
description of persons, there are to be found in the world.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account