Some possible bearings of genetics on pathologyMorgan, Thomas Hunt
Science
Some possible bearings of genetics on pathology
Morgan, Thomas Hunt
Diseases -- Causes and theories of causation; Genetics; Heredity; Pathology
Tyzzer and Little suggest in fact that 12 to 14 independently inherited
factors are involved. Larger numbers of tests will be necessary before
it is possible to state how many factors are needed. A curious feature
of the case should not pass unnoticed. Many or all of the factors for
_susceptibility_ must be assumed to be dominant. It is not generally
known, but there is some evidence that the so-called Japanese waltzer
originated from Asiatic house mice, which according to some writers
belong to a distinct species or at least a distinct variety. The
results suggest that we may be dealing here with species or varietal
differences, hence the large number of factor differences involved. It
may be necessary to work with a simpler situation where fewer factors are
involved; possibly such a case as that of the Jensen tumor will furnish
proper material, but it will be necessary to work with pedigreed material
rather than with “Danish,” “French,” “German,” or even English breeds of
mice.
[Illustration: FIG. 13. Diagram showing inheritance of immunity to
cancer. (From Tyzzer and Little.)]
In plants also the inheritance of immunity of wheat to rust has been
studied. Biffen’s results with wheat are those best known. An immune race
crossed to a susceptible race gave first generation plants that were
attacked. This means that immunity is a recessive character. In the next
generation there were 64 immune and 194 affected plants (a 1:3 ratio). If
the immune plants are self-fertilized, they yield only immune plants in
later generations.
Nilsson-Ehle and Vavilov think that such simple relations are rather the
exception than the rule. Vavilov found that Persian wheat, immune to
mildew, crossed to different susceptible species produced offspring that
were immune in 13 combinations. In these cases immunity is dominant.
In the next generation several degrees of resistance were noted—and a few
plants were even more susceptible than their grandparents.
It is interesting again to note that susceptibility and immunity are
species and variety characters in these cases, but this does not
mean that the differences are not Mendelian. It suggests however the
possibility that several or many factor differences are often involved.
There is no more interesting field in which genetics and pathology meet
than that of cancer. I realize how careful we on our side must be in
discussing this question with you who are experts, nevertheless there are
certain aspects of the problems of cancer from the genetic side that I
may be allowed briefly to mention—not, however, without some misgivings.
Suppose all men over seventy-five died of arteriosclerosis. Could one say
that hardening of the arteries is inherited? I think that it would be
proper to use the word heredity to include such a case, but we would not
know how it was inherited unless there existed another race of men who
never died of the malady, and suitable matings were made between the two
races.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account