Both tables show that Wellhausen's analysis of Q is much less elaborate than that of any of the other students. Since the number of Q verses which he finds in both Matthew and Luke is considerably larger than that which Harnack and Hawkins find, the disparity between his Q matter in Matthew and in Luke may be accounted for by his willingness to go farther beyond the duplicate material in those two Gospels for his Q. His two hundred and ten Q verses ascribed to Luke are not greatly in excess of the number ascribed by Harnack and Hawkins to both Luke and Matthew. He gives to Luke twenty more Q verses, and to Matthew sixty-six more, than Harnack. Of these sixty-six, he may consider thirty to be duplicates in Matthew and Luke (since what constitutes derivation from a common source must always be matter of opinion). The other thirty-six verses he assigns to Q in Matthew, tho lacking duplicates in Luke, on the ground of their general characteristics. The habits of Matthew and Luke, respectively, in their treatment of Mark, render it practically certain that Matthew would feel less at liberty to omit Q material than Luke. Wernle's assignments (three hundred and two Q verses to Matthew and two hundred and fifty-five to Luke) may be explained in the same way. TABLE III MATERIAL IN LUKE TAKEN FROM Q ================================================================= Chapter | Harnack |Wellhausen| Hawkins | J. Weiss | | | | | | --------|-------------|----------|----------------|-------------| iii |7-9, 16-17 |1-7 |7-9, 17 |7-9, 17-18 | iv |1-13 |1-15 |3-13 |1-13 | vi |17, 20-23, |20-23, |17, 20-23 |47-49 | | 27-33, | 27-49 | 27-49 | | | 35b-44, | | | | | 46-49 | | | | vii |1-10, 18-28, |1-10, |1-3, 6-9, 18-19,|1-3, 7-10, | | 31-35 | 18-35 | 22-28, | 18-26, | | | | 31-35 | 28-35 | ix |2, 57-60 | | 57-60 |57-60 | x |2-7b, 9, |1-24 |2-6, 7b-9, |2-3, 13-14, | | 16, 21-22, | | 12-16, | 16, 21-27 | | 23b, 24 | | 21-24 | | xi |2-4, 9-14, |9-32, |2-4, 9-14, |2-4, 9-11, | | 16-17, 19- | 37-52 | 16, 19-20, | 15-16, 24- | | 20, 23-26, | | 23-26, 29-32, | 26, 29-31, | | 29-35, 39, | | 34-35, | 33-35, | | 42, 44, | | 39, 41, 42, | 39-52 | | 46-52 | | 44, 46-51 | | xii |2-10, 22-31, |22-46 |2-9, 22-31, |2-8, 10-12, |