Sources of the Synoptic GospelsPatton, Carl S. (Carl Safford)
Religion
Sources of the Synoptic Gospels
Patton, Carl S. (Carl Safford)
Bible. Gospels -- Criticism, interpretation, etc.
This is one of the sections that point most clearly to different
recensions of Q in the hands of Matthew and Luke. It is improbable that
any collection of the sayings of Jesus should have lacked this prayer. It
is equally improbable that Luke could have had it before him in the more
elaborated form of Matthew, and have abridged it to suit himself.
Matthew's more elaborate form, on the other hand, does not sound like the
deliberate alteration of any one author, but like the accumulated
liturgical usage of the Christian community. Luke's introduction to the
prayer is certainly not his own invention, and is so appropriate that it
is hard to believe that Matthew found it in connection with the prayer in
his source and deliberately omitted it. Luke's form seems decidedly more
primary. The use in both Gospels of the strange word ἐπιούσιον seems to
carry the two traditions back to one original; but the variations are
certainly greater than can be accounted for by the literary habits of
Matthew and Luke, working upon the same original. In other words, that
original had passed thru a different history before it reached our two
evangelists. The section is assigned to QMt and QLk.
A SAYING ABOUT TREASURES
(Mt vi, 19-21; Lk xii, 33-34)
The verbal similarity is not close. Except for the proximity of other Q
material, the section might be assigned to two entirely different sources.
There is, especially, a quite different turn given to the saying in Luke,
from that which it has in Matthew, by the introduction of the words "Sell
your goods and give alms." In spite of Luke's interest in alms-giving, as
disclosed in the Book of Acts, it is hard to credit him with such a
re-wording of his text without some help from his source. But the last
twelve words in the section are identical in the two Gospels, except that
Luke uses the plural form of the pronoun where Matthew uses the singular.
Largely on account of these last twelve words the section is assigned to
QMt and QLk.
A SAYING ABOUT THE EYE
(Mt vi, 22-23; Lk xi, 34-35)
Of forty-four words in Matthew and forty in Luke, thirty-two are
identical. The divergences in the use of conjunctions (ὅταν for ἐὰν, e.g.)
and the improvement by condensation of the last sentence are such changes
as might be easily ascribed to Luke. The section may, with reasonable
assurance, be assigned merely to Q.
ABOUT DOUBLE SERVICE
(Mt vi, 24; Lk xvi, 13)
There are twenty-seven words in this saying according to Matthew,
twenty-eight according to Luke. Luke appears to have been the innovator;
his addition of οἰκέτης improves the sentence in a way often accomplished
by him. With the exception of the presence of this word in Luke and its
absence in Matthew the saying is identical in the two Gospels. It is
therefore assigned simply to Q.
ABOUT CARE
(Mt vi, 25-33; Lk xii, 22-31)
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account