Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for educationHollingworth, Leta Stetter
Science
Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for education
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Educational psychology; Educational tests and measurements; Exceptional children
Studies of left-handed children who have been “changed over” through
education or accident to the right hand, and of right-handed children
changed over through accident to the left hand, lead to the conclusion
that among them there is more nervousness and a greater number of speech
defects than would be allowed by the usual course of events. Stammering
is evidently a complication in some cases of modified handedness. The
physiology of this connection is obscure. In view of the fact that
speech defects occur to so great an extent in “changing over,” and that
we do not know the physiology of handedness, it seems by all means
wisest not to try to modify handedness where it is very pronounced. A
very right-handed person, fortunate in being with the majority, may, by
using for a week his left hand instead of his right, get an idea of what
is suffered by a very left-handed child being compelled to use the right
hand.
It has been reported that there is an undue proportion of left-handed
persons among criminals, mental defectives, and the insane. These
reports require careful verification. Criminals, mental defectives, and
the insane have been much more carefully scrutinized than have the
superior in intellect and character, or even than the average
population. The present writer has, during recent surveys, noticed
left-handed performance repeatedly in very gifted children, but has not
computed the proportion. Until further scrutinies have been made, it
cannot be said positively that left-handedness is correlated with
organic inferiority.
Perfectly satisfactory tests of handedness have not yet been agreed
upon. Jones proposed some years ago to measure congenital handedness by
means of a brachiometer. This is an instrument for measuring the bones
of the forearm, and by its use Jones hoped to detect handedness “at the
moment of birth” as well as on any subsequent day of life. These hopes
have not been realized in the findings of others who have given the
method fair trial, as Beeley did. Tapping, with the wrist movement,
tapping with fingers, tracing, spontaneous rubbing, throwing and picking
up, winding, and cutting with scissors are the most promising among
tests so far tried out, to discover whether a child is congenitally
left-handed. Gripping, as with the dynamometer, does not seem to
correlate so well with known facts, as do the other tests of movement.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account