Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for educationHollingworth, Leta Stetter
Science
Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for education
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Educational psychology; Educational tests and measurements; Exceptional children
Left-handedness as an element in individuality becomes conspicuous in
school procedure especially in writing, drawing, shop work, or any work
where the hand is an important factor in the performance. It may become
conspicuous in vocational endeavor, either as an asset or a handicap. In
a few kinds of performance, such as baseball or tennis, left-handedness
gives an advantage, all other things being equal. In most professional
pursuits (with the possible exception of dentistry and surgery because
of manufactured appliances) left-handedness is a matter of indifference.
In work with machines left-handedness is likely to be a handicap,
because machines are “right-handed.” Even scissors, eggbeaters,
typewriters, and other common appliances of office and home are
“right-handed.”
Left-handedness as a handicap in the absence of rational consideration
of it, is illustrated in an extreme fashion by the case of a young
pickpocket, remanded for mental examination upon second offense. This
boy was of average general intelligence, extremely left-handed, and a
stammerer. He had left school as soon as the law allowed, with a record
of chronic truancy behind him. He explained that he had always “hated
school,” because the teachers tried to make him right-handed, and
because he was so ashamed of his stammering. Obtaining his working
papers, he had first tried factory work, but the machines were all
right-handed. He had then taken “a job” as an office boy, but he had to
abandon that because he could not adequately answer the telephone, or
converse with those who questioned him. Being “fired,” he found a place
as packer of china in a department store, but had a fight with a fellow
worker, who mimicked him, and was dismissed. Soon thereafter, needing
money, he saw an opportunity to abstract a purse from a convenient
pocket, and did so. The success of this venture led to others like it,
until he was apprehended and sent to the reformatory. Having served his
time, he came out with this record added to his original difficulties,
and drifted again into picking pockets.
The history of this boy shows the adaptation to social environment of an
organism struggling by trial and error methods, without rational
guidance. A left-handed man can pick pockets as well as anyone else
(perhaps better), and speech defect is here no hindrance, since perfect
silence is observed in such pursuits.
This boy might have had a very different career if school and society
had given a different kind of consideration to his individuality.
III. MIRROR WRITING
A certain number of children, variously estimated, write backwards,
beginning at the right of the page. This is called “mirror writing,” and
is apparently a function of left-handedness. Baldwin’s description is
succinct.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account