Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for educationHollingworth, Leta Stetter
Science
Special talents and defects : $b Their significance for education
Hollingworth, Leta Stetter
Educational psychology; Educational tests and measurements; Exceptional children
“Mirror writing is the form of inscription which arises from tracing
words with the left hand by an exact reduplication of the movements of
the right hand, in a symmetrical way from the central point in front of
the body, out toward the left. It produces a form of reversed writing
which cannot be read until it is seen in a mirror. Many left-handed
children tend to write in this way. Some adults, on taking a pen to
write with the left hand, find they can write only in this way. Even
those, like myself, to whom the movements seem, when thought of in
visual terms, quite confusing and impossible, yet find when they try to
write with both hands together, in the air, from a central point right
and left, that the left hand mirror writing movements are very natural
and easy.”
Beeley conducted a survey, by questionnaire addressed to teachers, of
the prevalence of mirror writers in the elementary schools of Chicago.
He thus found one mirror writer to every 2500 children. Gordon by actual
tests of writing found a larger proportion of mirror writers, about
one-half of one per cent. Among feeble-minded children in special
schools the percentage appears to be much greater, in fact, about
seventeen times as great, according to Gordon’s findings.
All investigators agree that mirror writers are almost always
left-handed by test, though the writing may be done with the left hand,
or with the right. As to the hand used in producing the writing there is
disagreement among investigators. Gordon found that “the mirror writers
were nearly always left-handed children who wrote with the right hand.”
Beeley says: “All of the mirror writers write mirror-wise with the left
hand. The only instances of right-hand mirror writing found were a few
upper-grade pupils who having seen this kind of writing naturally
executed by mirror writers, attempted to imitate the same.”
The origin of mirror writing is not fully explained as yet. It is
probably the natural mode for left-handed persons, as attempts to write
with both hands indicate. Yet not all left-handed persons acquire this
habit. Obviously the mirror writer is not corrected in his fault by
notice of the discrepancies between the visual and the motor. It may be
that those left-handed children who become mirror writers are usually
deficient in visual perception of letters or words, or generally
deficient. That there are, however, bright children who form this habit
is shown by the surveys made.
Samples of mirror writing by school children are shown in Figure 27. In
order to correct the difficulty, visual control of movement must be
cultivated. Attempts to correct by changing over to the right hand are
injudicious, for the reasons cited under the discussion of
left-handedness.
[Illustration:
FIG. 27.—Showing mirror writing by public school pupils. (From
Beeley’s _An Experimental Study of Left-Handedness_. Reproduced by
courtesy of the University of Chicago Press.)
]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account