Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and CivilizationMumford, Lewis
History
Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and Civilization
Mumford, Lewis
Architecture -- United States
The Renaissance in architecture had reached England at about the time
of the Great Fire (1666), fully two generations after the Italian
influence had made its way into English literature; and it came to
America, as one might guess, about a generation later. It was left
for Alexander Pope, who himself was a dutiful Augustan, to sum up the
situation with classic precision to Lord Burlington, who had published
Palladio’s Antiquities of Rome:
“You show us Rome was glorious, not profuse,
And pompous buildings once were things of use.
Yet shall, my lord, your just and noble rules
Fill half the land with imitation fools;
Who random drawings from your sheets shall take
And of one beauty many blunders make.”
These lines were a warning and a prophecy. The warning was timely;
and the prophecy came true, except in those districts in which the
carpenter continued to ply his craft without the overlordship of the
architect.
III
The first effect of the Renaissance forms in America was not to
destroy the vernacular but to perfect it; for it provided the
carpenter-builder, whose distance from Europe kept him from profiting
by the spirited work of his forbears, with a series of ornamental
motifs. New England, under the influence of an idol-breaking
Puritanism, had been singularly poor in decoration, as I have already
observed: its modest architectural effects relied solely on mass,
color, and a nice disposition of parts. In its decorative aspects
medievalism had left but a trace in America: the carved grotesque
heads on the face of the Van Cortlandt Mansion in New York, and the
painted decorations in some of the older houses and barns among the
Pennsylvania Dutch pretty well complete the tally.
Classical motifs served to fill the blank in provincial architecture.
As long as the carpenter worked by himself, the classic influence
was confined to little details like the fanlights, the moldings, the
pillars of the portico, and so on. In the rural districts of New
England, from Maine to Connecticut, and in certain parts of New York
and New Jersey and Pennsylvania, the carpenter keeps on building in his
solid, traditional manner down to the time that the jig-saw overwhelms
a mechanically hypnotized age; and even through the jig-saw period
in the older regions, the proportions and the plan remained close to
tradition. The classical did not in fact supplant the vernacular until
the last vestiges of the guild and the village-community had passed
away, and the economic conditions appropriate to the Renaissance
culture had made their appearance.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account