Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and CivilizationMumford, Lewis
History
Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and Civilization
Mumford, Lewis
Architecture -- United States
With the new forces that were at work on the American scene, with
the disintegration of classical culture under the combined influence
of pioneer enterprise, mechanical invention, overseas commerce,
and the almost religious cult of utilitarianism, all this was
indeed inevitable. What happened to the proud, Roman-patterned
republic of 1789 is a matter of common knowledge. Benjamin Latrobe,
the British architect who contributed so much to the Capitol at
Washington--including a new order of corn stalks and tobacco
leaves--was a witness to the disintegration of the age and the
dissolution of its world of ideas; and there is a familiar ring to his
commentary upon it:
“I remember [he says in his autobiography] the time when I was over
head and ears in love with Man in a State of Nature.... Social
Compacts were my hobbies; the American Revolution--I ask its pardon,
for it deserves better company--was a sort of dream of the Golden
Age; and the French Revolution was the Golden Age itself. I should
be ashamed to confess all this if I had not a thousand companions
in my kaleidoscopic amusement, and those generally men of ardent,
benevolent, and well-informed minds and excellent hearts. Alas!
experience has destroyed the illusion, the kaleidoscope is broken,
and all the tinsel of scenery that glittered so delightfully is
translated and turned to raggedness. A dozen years’ residence at the
Republican court of Washington had affected wonderfully the advance
of riper years.”
Major L’Enfant’s plan for Washington was the last gasp, it seems to me,
of the classical order; Jefferson’s University of Virginia was perhaps
its most perfect consummation, for Jefferson had planned for the life
of the institution as well as for the shell which was to contain it.
Before the nineteenth century was long under way men’s minds ceased
to move freely within the classical idolum; and by 1860 the mood
was obliterated and a large part of the work had been submerged or
destroyed. The final ironic commentary upon the dignity and austerity
of the earlier temples is illustrated in a house in Kennebunkport,
Maine; for there the serene, pillared façade is broken up in the rear
by a later, and alas! a necessary addition: a two-story bow-window
projected far enough beyond the eaves to give a little light to the
occupants of the rooms!
In sum, there was a pathetic incompatibility in this architecture
between need and achievement, between pretensions and matter-of-fact--a
rigid opposition to common sense that a vernacular, however playful,
would never countenance. These temples were built with the marmoreal
gesture of eternity; they satisfied the desire and fashion of the
moment; and today their ghosts parade before us, brave but incredible.
CHAPTER FOUR THE DIASPORA OF THE PIONEER
I
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account