Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and CivilizationMumford, Lewis
History
Sticks and Stones: A Study of American Architecture and Civilization
Mumford, Lewis
Architecture -- United States
So much of the detail of a building is established by factory standards
and patterns that even the patron himself has precious little scope
for giving vent to his impulses in the design or execution of the
work; for every divergence from a standardized design represents an
additional expense. In fact, the only opportunity for expressing his
taste and personality is in choosing the mode in which the house is to
be built: he must find his requirements in Italy, Colonial America,
France, Tudor England, or Spain--woe to him if he wants to find them
in twentieth-century America! Thus the machine process has created a
standardized conception of style: of itself it can no more invent a new
style than a mummy can beget children. If one wishes a house of red
brick it will be Georgian or Colonial; that is to say, the trimming
will be white, the woodwork will have classic moldings, and the
electric-light fixtures will be pseudo-candlesticks in silvered metal.
If one builds a stucco house, one is doomed by similar mechanical
canons to rather heavy furniture in the early Renaissance forms,
properly duplicated by the furniture makers of Grand Rapids--and so on.
The notion of an American stucco house is so foreign to the conception
of the machine mode that only the very poor, and the very rich, can
afford it. Need I add that Colonial or Italian, when it falls from the
mouth of the “realtor” has nothing to do with authentic Colonial or
Italian work?
Commercial concentration and the national market waste resources by
neglect, as in the case of the Appalachian forests they squandered
them by pillage. Standardized materials and patterns and plans and
elevations--here are the ingredients of the architecture of the machine
age: by escaping it we get our superficially vivacious suburbs; by
accepting it, those vast acres of nondescript monotony that, call
them West Philadelphia or Long Island City or what you will, are but
the anonymous districts of Coketown. The chief thing needful for the
full enjoyment of this architecture is a standardized people. Here our
various educational institutions, from the advertising columns of the
five-cent magazine to the higher centers of learning, from the movie to
the radio, have not perhaps altogether failed the architect.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account