Studies of Birds Killed in Nocturnal MigrationTordoff, Harrison Bruce
Science
Studies of Birds Killed in Nocturnal Migration
Tordoff, Harrison Bruce
Birds -- Migration
One is left with the impression that the whole subject is still
unsettled. While earlier workers sought to reduce the entire matter to
law, the latest disclaim the possibility of generalization. After
summarizing Brewster's and Gätke's opinions, Thomson (1926:79) wrote:
"It would seem, in any event, that no general rule can be laid down."
Meinertzhagen's summation (1930:56-57) still represents fairly well
the status of our knowledge: "Order of sex and age on autumn passage
is very difficult to arrive at, as evidence is conflicting. But, on
the whole, it seems that birds flock together, old and young,
preparatory to moving south, and do in many cases initiate migration
in company.... But once movement is initiated, among birds which do
not habitually fraternise in flocks, adults, and especially males,
will naturally outstrip the less virile females and still less virile
offspring.... The consequence is that any observer at an intermediate
station such as Heligoland is, in noting birds of the year as first
arrivals, has not had an opportunity of noting the flocks of adults
which have passed without alighting. On the other hand, there is very
definite evidence to show that among certain species, adults follow
their offspring on migration. The reason for different behaviour
among different types of birds remains obscure." We regard much of
this as still theory.
[Illustration: FIG. 1. Composition by age and sex as found in one or
more series of each of eight species of birds included in the Topeka
sample. Each separate series is represented by a single histogram, the
histograms for a species being grouped with the earliest series on the
left. Each histogram expresses the numbers of adults (left-hand
column) and immatures (right-hand column) in terms of percentage of
the whole series. Thus the two bars of each couplet add up to 100 per
cent. The hatched portion of each bar represents males, the clear
portion females.]
It would be difficult to imagine a better way of resolving the
problems and uncertainties just reviewed than by the detailed
analysis of large samples of migratory birds killed at random at
various points and times. An analysis of the sample of birds
accidentally killed at Topeka is presented here as an initial step in
this direction. Although the conclusions based on this sample are
tentative and may in time be altered, the data themselves are
definite. If this general type of analysis is repeated again and
again--applied to samples taken on many dates and in many
localities--a mass of hitherto unparalleled evidence for the study of
migration will emerge.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account