Studies of the Greek Poets (Vol 1 of 2)Symonds, John Addington
History
Studies of the Greek Poets (Vol 1 of 2)
Symonds, John Addington
Greek poetry -- History and criticism
NOTE.--I wish to qualify what I have said upon pp. 67-80
by stating that my critique of the linguistic and solar
theories is not, as I hope, directed in any impertinent spirit
against the illustrious teacher to whom, in common with most
Englishmen, I owe nearly all my knowledge of comparative
mythology, but rather against notions which have gained
currency through a too exclusive attention to the origin of
Greek mythology. I want to remind students of Greek literature
that, after all they may have learned from Sanscrit, they are
still upon the threshold of mythology as it was determined by
the genius of the Greek race. There is a danger of diverting
the mind from questions of thoughts to questions of words, and
leading people to fancy that etymological solutions are final.
FOOTNOTES:
[8] For this reason the analogy of existing barbarous races will not
help us much, inasmuch as they are not Greeks nor destined to be
Greeks. This consideration ought to weigh with those who, struck by
the depth and beauty of some Greek myths, theorize a corruption of
primitive revelation or pure theology to explain them. They ought to
remember that they are dealing with the myths of Greeks--our masters in
philosophy and poetry and art.
[9] The original is quoted in the Notes to Grote, vol. i. p. 474.
[10] The dissimilarity between Greek and Roman religion has often been
observed, and will be touched upon below. Supposing it to be proved
that the Romans can produce one relic of an Aryan myth in Romulus,
we find that their most native deities--Saturnus, Ops, Bellona,
Janus, Terminus, Concordia, Fides, Bonus Eventus, and so forth--are
abstractions which have nothing in common with Greek or other Aryan
legends. They are the characteristic product of the Roman mind, and
indicate its habit of thought. In like manner it is only by a crasis
amounting to confusion that Mercurius can be identified with Hermes, or
Hercules with Herakles.
[11] ii. 44.
CHAPTER III.
_ACHILLES._
Unity of _Iliad_.--Character of Achilles.--Structure of the
whole Poem.--Comparison with other Epics.--Energy Dividing
into Anger and Love.--Personality of Achilles.--The Quarrel
with Agamemnon.--Pallas Athene.--The Embassy.--Achilles'
Foreknowledge of his Death.--The Message of
Antilochus.--Interview with Thetis.--The Shouting in
the Trench.--The Speech of Xanthus.--The Pæan over
Hector's Corpse.--The Ghost of Patroclus.---The Funeral
Obsequies of Patroclus.--Achilles and Priam.--Achilles in
Hades.--Achilles Considered as a Greek Ideal.--Friendship
among the Greeks.--Heroism and Knighthood: Ancient and
Modern Chivalry.--The _Myrmidones_ of Æschylus.--Achilles
and Hector.--Alexander the Great.--The Dæmonic Nature of
Achilles.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account