Suicide: Its History, Literature, Jurisprudence, Causation, and PreventionWestcott, W. Wynn (William Wynn)
Philosophy
Suicide: Its History, Literature, Jurisprudence, Causation, and Prevention
Westcott, W. Wynn (William Wynn)
Suicide
Aristotle narrates that a horse having been induced to have connection
with his own dam, by the artifice of veiling her, for he had refused to
do so previously, on seeing what he had done, jumped intentionally from
a cliff, and was killed by the fall. See History of Animals, lib. ix.,
cap. 47.
But Professor Axe, of the Royal Veterinary College, tells me that he
has never heard of _such_ a refusal on the part of a horse, neither
has he ever observed any instance which seemed to him to point to the
intentional self-destruction of any animal.
There is an old story mentioned in Boswell’s Life of Johnson, that a
scorpion if irritated by placing it within a ring of burning coals,
will thrust its own sting into itself, and so commit suicide; Dr.
Johnson doubted it, and remarked that Maupertuis did not credit it.
Bory de St. Vincent, in the classic “Dictionnaire d’Histoire
Naturelle,” vol. 15, says he has tried the experiment, and the
scorpions simply became suffocated.
There is reference to the suicide of scorpions in Nature, Vol. xi., p.
29, which speaks of irritating a scorpion by means of a burning glass,
with the same result. In the next week’s number, p. 47, is another
mention of a similar observation. At Vol. xx., p. 553, a writer denies
the possibility of a scorpion striking itself, whilst at p. 577, Prof.
Allen Thompson details hearsay instances of scorpions forcibly piercing
their own heads by their recurved stings, when annoyed by a bright
light.
Youatt, Wm., V. S., tells the story of an artillery horse which refused
food, and died from starvation, after the death of another horse, with
which he had long worked. See “The Horse.”
Dr. W. L. Lindsay is a copious writer on this subject. He fully
believes in animal suicide, and speaks of old age, wounded feelings,
pain, desperation, continued ill usage, captivity, and self-sacrifice
as causes; and states that he has notes of instances occurring in the
dog, horse, mule, camel, llama, ass, monkey, seal and deer; stork,
cock, jackdaw and duck; spider and scorpion; he narrates also some of
the cases for which I have given references. See “Mind in the Lower
Animals.”
He gives also many very interesting examples of accidental
self-destruction, such as the strangling of horses by their halters,
when endeavouring to escape from a stable; that monkeys have cut their
throats from imitating a man shaving; and that mice have been poisoned
by eating greenbacks.
Some sorts of fish, as salmon, have been noticed to throw themselves
out of the water, but it seems very doubtful whether this act is meant
to be suicidal.
Voluntary deaths of animals during panic and terror, and from
fascination, seem to intervene between accidental suicides, and
suicides which appear to be the result of choice; such deaths are
caused by the headlong flight of sheep when worried by a dog, or are
caused by fires on the prairies; or by fascination, as seen in the case
of moths in a candle flame.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account