Superstition and Force: Essays on the Wager of Law, the Wager of Battle, the Ordeal, TortureLea, Henry Charles
History
Superstition and Force: Essays on the Wager of Law, the Wager of Battle, the Ordeal, Torture
Lea, Henry Charles
Ordeal; Torture; Wager of battle; Wager of law
the close of the fifteenth century provided no other penalty for murder
than a _wer-gild_ to be divided among the kindred and friends of the
slain; and during the fifteenth century there was only a short term of
imprisonment added.[10] Among the southern Slavs the Zadruga takes the
place of the Russian Mir, and is a still more absolute and primitive
form of family organization.[11]
In obedience to this all-pervading tendency of organization, the
barbarian tribes which overthrew the Roman Empire based their
institutions on two general principles—the independence of the
individual freeman and the solidarity of the family group—and on these
were founded their simple forms of jurisprudence. As the criminal
was not responsible to the state, but to the injured party, personal
punishments were unknown, and the law made no attempt to decree
them. All that it could do was to provide rude courts before which
a plaintiff could state his case, and a settled tariff of pecuniary
compensation to console him for his sufferings.[12] If he disdained
this peaceful process, he was at liberty to assemble his kindred and
friends, and exact what satisfaction he could with sword and axe.
The offender, moreover, could not legitimately refuse to appear when
summoned before the _mallum_, or judicial assembly of the tribe;
nor could he, as a rule, claim the right of armed defence, if the
complainant preferred to receive the money payment provided for the
offence of which he might prove his antagonist guilty.
This _wer-gild_ was in no sense a fine inflicted as a punishment for
guilt, but only a compensation to induce the injured party to forego
his right of reprisals, and the interest which society felt in it
was not in the repression of crime, but in the maintenance of peace
by averting the endless warfare of hostile families. An Anglo-Saxon
proverb, quoted approvingly in the laws of Edward the Confessor, as
collected by William the Conqueror, says: “Bicge spere of side oðer
bere”—Buy off the spear from thy side or endure it.[13] The application
of the system is to be seen in the minute and complex tariffs of crime
which form so large a portion of the barbarian codes. Every attempt
against person and property is rated at its appropriate price, from the
theft of a sucking pig to the armed occupation of an estate, and from a
wound of the little finger to the most atrocious of parricides. To what
extent this at last was carried may be seen in the Welsh codes, where
every hair of the eyelash is rated at a penny.[14]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account