Surgical Experiences in South Africa, 1899-1900: Being Mainly a Clinical Study of the Nature and Effects of Injuries Produced by Bullets of Small Calibre — John Shaqi
Surgical Experiences in South Africa, 1899-1900: Being Mainly a Clinical Study of the Nature and Effects of Injuries Produced by Bullets of Small CalibreMakins, George Henry
History
Surgical Experiences in South Africa, 1899-1900: Being Mainly a Clinical Study of the Nature and Effects of Injuries Produced by Bullets of Small Calibre
Makins, George Henry
Gunshot wounds; South African War, 1899-1902; Surgery, Military
The Stationary hospitals (by which I intend to indicate those receiving
the patients directly from the Field hospitals before the establishment
of advanced Base hospitals), as already indicated, were not in my
opinion so perfectly conceived or organised. The requirements of these
are, however, far greater than those of the Field hospitals, and they of
all others are dependent on the possession of facilities for rapid
transport. In South Africa the difficulties of supplying them were
enormous, and no doubt the conditions of the campaign in this, as so
many other particulars, were novel and unusual. None the less the
experience gained will no doubt be utilised in the future. With regard
to the extravagant criticisms levelled at the Field hospitals serving as
Stationary hospitals at the time of the early period of the occupation
of Bloemfontein, it may be pointed out that the only proper ground for
comparison was not between the patients at Bloemfontein and those in
hospital at the base, but between the men in hospital and those in the
field at that time, since the conditions were equally adverse to both.
Besides, it must not be forgotten that a large proportion of the
patients, at that time, were really comfortably housed in the Raadzaal
and other buildings, the preparation of which entailed a very great
amount of both labour and resource.
The difficulties experienced at that time will, it is hoped, go far
towards securing greater facilities and rights of transport to the Royal
Army Medical Corps in the future. As a civilian, one cannot but
recognise that the conditions of modern warfare are much altered from
those of the past. Prisoners are well cared for and kindly treated, the
sick and wounded are respected by both sides, and except in the actual
horrors of fighting the condition of the soldier is a happier one. Under
these circumstances the limitation of the transport facilities of a
department so closely concerned with the well-being of all, and which
has been organised on a most moderate scale, must soon become a
tradition of the past in civilised armies.
As to the efficiency of the organisation of the General hospitals,
either at the advanced or actual base, I have already testified.
Naturally the working of these hospitals varied with the personal
equation of the officer in charge of them, but as a whole the service
has every reason to be proud of their success. As far as surgical
results are concerned, and with these I had special acquaintance, the
success of the hospitals was amply demonstrated.
Adverse criticism was not however wanting, and often expressed in the
strongest terms by persons totally unacquainted with hospital methods,
and apparently unconscious that such excellence as is exhibited in a
London hospital is the result of continuous work and development for
some centuries, and that such institutions are worked by committees and
staffs of permanent constitution.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account