Sweated industry and the minimum wageBlack, Clementina
History
Sweated industry and the minimum wage
Black, Clementina
Minimum wage; Sweatshops
The foregoing chapters will have been written in vain if they have not
succeeded in showing that there is no necessary connection between high
wages and high selling prices; but that, on the contrary, high wages, in
the great majority of cases, actually conduce to cheap production. Were
this invariably the case, it is obvious that a general rise of wages,
far from encouraging foreign competition, would rather form a barrier
against it. And this, in fact, would be—as it is in some instances
already—the case in many trades.
It may be well briefly to consider the various groups of cases that
would arise in consequence of a general rise in the remuneration of
labour. There exists, in the first place, a considerable group of trades
in which, for similar work in respect of goods sold at the same price,
different employers pay very different rates of wage. A very remarkable
instance is furnished, in one of the worst paid trades, by the shirt
factory of the Scottish Wholesale Co-operative Society. In that
establishment, turning out goods for working class customers, women have
for years received about double the wages of the average home working
shirt maker, they not providing, as does she, the sewing cotton used. In
October 1906 the average wage paid to workers in this factory was 18s.
3d. per week, and their week was one of 44 hours.[98] Yet the factory
pays and has done so for many years.[99]
It is therefore clear that even in the ready made shirt trade it is
possible to pay reasonably good wages, to compete with the “sweater,”
and yet to make a profit. Thus the enforcement of a minimum weekly wage
very near the level of Mr Maxwell’s 18s. 3d. would neither kill the
trade nor stimulate the importation of foreign shirts. It would merely
impose upon other employers that standard of management and methods
which Mr Maxwell has chosen voluntarily to adopt. Those employers who
lacked intelligence or flexibility to carry on a factory on these terms
would, it is true, be driven out of business; but their customers would
not cease to buy nor to be supplied at the old price. The only change
would be that none of us would, any longer, be buying shirts at which
some woman had sewn, as Hood said,
“with a double thread
At once a shirt and a shroud.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account