Sweated industry and the minimum wageBlack, Clementina
History
Sweated industry and the minimum wage
Black, Clementina
Minimum wage; Sweatshops
There are other groups of trades in which the history of the cotton
trade would be repeated, that is to say, the employer who found himself
compelled to pay higher wages would at once introduce better
machinery—either in the narrow sense of actual appliances or in the
wider sense of improved organisation and management. Such an employer
would also, as the cotton masters have done, demand better work from his
employees, and would get it. At first there might be a diminution in the
number of hands employed; but if, as almost always happens, the improved
methods led to a considerable reduction in the cost of production and
consequently to a lowered selling price, demand would immediately
increase, and more workers would again be wanted. There is no reason in
the nature of things why a rise of wages and a powerful labour
organisation should not do for the silk trade and the woollen trade of
Britain what they have already done for the cotton trade.
In the first group of these trades, then, no workers would be displaced,
and the conditions of the market would remain unaltered; in the second,
there would, at first, probably be a displacement and afterwards,
probably, a renewed, or even an increased demand for workers.
We come next to a group of trades which may exist, but of the existence
of which I personally am somewhat sceptical. These are the trades in
which there is neither margin of profit nor room for improvements that
might make up for the additional outlay upon heightened wages. In these
trades—if such there be—it is undeniable that if British wages rose
while foreign wages remained stationary the foreigner would be extremely
likely to capture the market.
But there are various matters that must be set down upon the other side
of the account. To begin with, our foreign competitors are themselves
uneasy about the existence of sweating within their borders. It is
almost certain that German legislation directed against this evil will
precede legislation in this country; while in America, as may indeed be
judged by the quotations from recent American books that appear in these
pages, there are many persons much concerned with the problem of
underpaid labour. If our foreign competitors should keep step with
ourselves in the prohibition of extreme underpayment, the balance of
international trade would be in no way disturbed. Nay, if only Germany
should do so, the disturbance to the English market would not be
serious.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account