Also the first and second Propositions contain the Pair of
codivisional Classes "cats" and "cats"; the first and third
contain the Pair "creatures understanding French" and "creatures
understanding French"; and the second and third contain the Pair
"chickens" and "chickens".
pg058
Also the three Propositions are (as we shall see at p. 64) so
related that, if the first two were true, the third would be
true. (The first two are, as it happens, _not_ strictly true in
_our_ planet. But there is nothing to hinder them from being
true in some _other_ planet, say _Mars_ or _Jupiter_--in which
case the third would _also_ be true in that planet, and its
inhabitants would probably engage chickens as
nursery-governesses. They would thus secure a singular
_contingent_ privilege, unknown in England, namely, that they
would be able, at any time when provisions ran short, to utilise
the nursery-governess for the nursery-dinner!)
Hence the Trio is a _Syllogism_; the Genus "creatures" is its
'Univ.'; the two Propositions, "All cats understand French" and
"Some chickens are cats", are its _Premisses_, the Proposition
"Some chickens understand French" is its _Conclusion_; the Terms
"cats" and "cats" are its _Eliminands_; and the Terms,
"creatures understanding French" and "chickens", are its
_Retinends_.
Hence we may write it thus:--
"All cats understand French;
Some chickens are cats;
.'. Some chickens understand French".]
pg059
CHAPTER II.
_PROBLEMS IN SYLLOGISMS._
§ 1.
_Introductory._
When the Terms of a Proposition are represented by _words_, it is said
to be '=concrete='; when by _letters_, '=abstract=.'
To translate a Proposition from concrete into abstract form, we fix on a
Univ., and regard each Term as a _Species_ of it, and we choose a letter
to represent its _Differentia_.
[For example, suppose we wish to translate "Some soldiers are
brave" into abstract form. We may take "men" as Univ., and
regard "soldiers" and "brave men" as _Species_ of the _Genus_
"men"; and we may choose x to represent the peculiar Attribute
(say "military") of "soldiers," and y to represent "brave." Then
the Proposition may be written "Some military men are brave
men"; _i.e._ "Some x-men are y-men"; _i.e._ (omitting "men," as
explained at p. 26) "Some x are y."
In practice, we should merely say "Let Univ. be "men",
x = soldiers, y = brave", and at once translate "Some soldiers
are brave" into "Some x are y."]
The Problems we shall have to solve are of two kinds, viz.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account