Tantalus : $b or, The future of ManSchiller, F. C. S. (Ferdinand Canning Scott)
Philosophy
Tantalus : $b or, The future of Man
Schiller, F. C. S. (Ferdinand Canning Scott)
Civilization; Eugenics
Accordingly, no one familiar with the actual working of academic
institutions is likely to fall into the error of pinning his faith to
them. They are, of course, designed for the purpose of preserving and
promoting the highest and most advanced knowledge hitherto attained:
but do they anywhere fulfil this purpose? Its execution must of
necessity be left to professors not exempt from human frailty, always
selected by more or less defective methods, whose interests by no
means coincide with those of their subjects. The interest of the
subject is to become more widely understood and so more influential.
The interest of the professor is to become more unassailable, and so
more authoritative. He achieves this by becoming more technical. For
the more technical he gets, the fewer can comprehend him; the fewer
are competent to criticize him, the more of an oracle he becomes; if,
therefore, he wishes for an easy life of undisturbed academic leisure,
the more he will indulge his natural tendency to grow more technical as
his knowledge grows, the more he will turn away from those aspects of
his subject which have any direct practical or human interest. He will
wrap himself in mysteries of technical jargon, and become as nearly
as possible unintelligible. Truly, as William James once exclaimed to
me, apropos of the policy of certain philosophers, “the natural enemy
of any subject is the professor thereof!” It is clear that if these
tendencies are allowed to prevail, every subject must in course of time
become unteachable, and not worth learning.
Thus educational systems become the chief enemies of education, and
seats of learning the chief obstacles to the growth of knowledge, while
in an otherwise stagnant or decadent society these tendencies sooner
or later get the upper hand and utterly corrupt the social memory.
The power of the professor is revealed not so much by the things he
teaches, as by the things he fails or refuses to teach.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account