Ten Great Religions: An Essay in Comparative TheologyClarke, James Freeman
Islamic
Ten Great Religions: An Essay in Comparative Theology
Clarke, James Freeman
Christianity and other religions; Religions
"Oriental scholars are frequently suspected of a desire to make the
literature of the Eastern nations appear more ancient than it is. As to
myself, I can truly say that nothing would be to me a more welcome
discovery, nothing would remove so many doubts and difficulties, as
some suggestions as to the manner in which certain of the Vedic hymns
could have been added to the original collection during the Brâhmana or
Sûtra periods, or, if possible, by the writers of our MSS., of which
most are not older than the fifteenth century. But these MSS., though
so modern, are checked by the Anukramanis. Every hymn which stands in
our MSS. is counted in the Index of Saunaka, who is anterior to the
invasion of Alexander. The Sûtras, belonging to the same period as
Saunaka, prove the previous existence of every chapter of the
Brâhmanas; and I doubt whether there is a single hymn in the Sanhitâ
of the Rig-Veda which could not be checked by some passage of the
Brâhmanas and Sûtras. The chronological limits assigned to the Sûtra
and Brâhmana periods will seem to most Sanskrit scholars too narrow
rather than too wide, and if we assign but two hundred years to the
Mantra period, from 800 to 1000 B.C., and an equal number to the
Chhandas period, from 1000 to 1200 B.C., we can do so only under the
supposition that during the early periods of history the growth of the
human mind was more luxuriant than in later times, and that the layers
of thought were formed less slowly in the primary than in the tertiary
ages of the world."
The Vedic age, according to Müller, will then be as follows:--
Sûtra period, from B.C. 200 to B.C. 600.
Brâhmana period, " " 600 " 800.
Mantra period, " " 800 " 1000.
Chhandas period, " " 1000 " 1200.
Dr. Haug, a high authority, considers the Vedic period to extend from B.C.
1200 to B.C. 2000, and the very oldest hymns to have been composed B.C.
2400.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account