Terpander; or, Music and the futureDent, Edward J. (Edward Joseph)
Philosophy
Terpander; or, Music and the future
Dent, Edward J. (Edward Joseph)
Music -- Philosophy and aesthetics
There need not really be anything so very terrifying about the
abandonment of the classical system. After all, we can always go back
to it when we feel inclined, just as we may take up Dante and return to
mediaeval astronomy. The lurking fear which besets us is perhaps that
if we abandoned ourselves to the artistic adventure of modern music we
might find, not merely that we did not particularly enjoy it, but that
somehow it had made it impossible for us to go back wholeheartedly to
the music of our youth. It is impossible. Everybody has to ask himself
the question and answer it for himself honestly――am I ready and keen
to face fresh intellectual adventures? As age increases, increasing
vanity has to be taken into account. We elderly people are easily prone
to deceive ourselves and to think that we can convince others of the
doctrine that connoisseurship is an adequate substitute for direct
enjoyment.
XV
Some of the composers of the present day appear to be pursuing
adventure in a definitely intellectual spirit comparable almost to
that of the mediaeval Netherlanders. Their admirers often seem to be
somewhat at a loss to expound their music to the uninitiated. They
draw our attention to various technical ingenuities and they insist,
no doubt justly, on the entire sincerity of the composers. As regards
sincerity, it is a virtue with which art has no concern. As regards
technical ingenuities, we have learned too many lessons from the
past. There are many devices which look quite amusing on paper, but
which in practical performance pass unnoticed. To this the composer
may reasonably reply that the perception and enjoyment of technical
ingenuities in performance is a matter of practice and experience;
there is no reason why he should compose music for fools. Ingenuity is
by no means a quality to be despised; there are innumerable moments
in the works of Purcell, Bach and Mozart at which technical ingenuity
has brought about some peculiarly poignant expression of beauty.
Constructive skill――and this is what is really meant by the musician’s
technical word _form_――is what makes music an art; and constructive
skill has to be attained by study and experiment. It is desirable too
that listeners should be trained in its appreciation, not so much by
books and lectures as by the actual experience of hearing.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account