And now, what is the purpose, and what the origin, of song? Is it, as
some naturalists have conceived, a means of raising the emotional tone
of the female, of creating a more effective pairing situation, and so
of removing a barrier to the successful discharge of the sexual
function; or, is the emphasis here too much upon the emotional, too
little upon the strictly utilitarian, aspect? All, I think, will agree
that it must serve some biological purpose, and the position we have so
far reached is that the determining condition of its manifestation is
not merely the establishment, but the actual occupation of a territory,
and that there are no factors in the external environment which can
evoke response in the absence of such condition. This being so, the
further questions arise as to whether it contributes towards the
attainment of the end for which the whole territorial system has been
built up, and what precisely is the way in which it does so.
Everyone knows that in the spring the shyest of birds no longer practise
the art of concealment. The Curlew soars to a great height, and upon
outstretched wings hovers in the air whilst uttering its plaintive wail;
the cock Grouse, as if dissatisfied with its "crowing," springs into the
air and becomes a conspicuous object of the moor; the wary Redshank,
poised on flickering wings, forgets its mournful alarm cry, and finds
again its melodious song; and even the secretive Grasshopper-Warbler
crawls out of the midst of the thicket in order to "reel," just as, for
a similar reason, Savi's Warbler climbs to the top of a tall reed. In
fact the males of most species, when they are finally established on the
breeding grounds, make themselves as conspicuous as possible by sight
and by sound. And since the sounds produced by no two species are
exactly alike, the females are able to recognise their prospective
mates, and the males that are still in search of ground have ample
warning if that upon which they are treading is already occupied. So
that you see, from the remarkable development of the vocal powers in the
male, there follow two important results--"recognition" and "warning."
We here turn from song as the expression of an instinctive disposition,
and the question of what calls forth this expression, to the impression
produced by the song on the hearer.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account