One thing which emerges is that physics tells us much less about
the physical world than we thought it did. Almost all the “great
principles” of traditional physics turn out to be like the “great
law” that there are always three feet to a yard; others turn out to
be downright false. The conservation of mass may serve to illustrate
both these misfortunes to which a “law” is liable. Mass used to be
defined as “quantity of matter,” and as far as experiment showed it
was never increased or diminished. But with the greater accuracy of
modern measurements, curious things were found to happen. In the first
place, the mass as measured was found to increase with the velocity;
this kind of mass was found to be really the same thing as energy. This
kind of mass is not constant for a given body, but the total amount of
it in the universe is conserved, or at least obeys a law very closely
analogous to conservation. This law itself, however, is to be regarded
as a truism, of the nature of the “law” that there are three feet to a
yard; it results from our methods of measurement, and does not express
a genuine property of matter. The other kind of mass, which we may call
“proper mass,” is that which is found to be the mass by an observer
moving with the body. This is the ordinary terrestrial case, where
the body we are weighing is not flying through the air. The “proper
mass” of a body is very nearly constant, but not quite, and the total
amount of “proper mass” in the world is not quite constant. One would
suppose that if you have four one-pound weights, and you put them all
together into the scales, they will together weigh four pounds. This is
a fond delusion: they weigh rather less, though not enough less to be
discovered by even the most careful measurements. In the case of four
hydrogen atoms, however, when they are put together to make one helium
atom, the defect is noticeable; the helium atom weighs measurably less
than four separate hydrogen atoms.
Broadly speaking, traditional physics has collapsed into two portions,
truisms and geography. There are, however, newer portions of physics,
such as the theory of quanta, which do not come under this head, but
appear to give genuine knowledge of laws reached by experiment.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account