We are apt to think that, for really careful measurements, it is better
to use a steel rod than a live eel. This is a mistake: not because
the eel tells us what the steel rod was thought to tell, but because
the steel rod really tells no more than the eel obviously does. The
point is, not that eels are really rigid, but that steel rods really
wriggle. To an observer in just one possible state of motion, the eel
would appear rigid, while the steel rod would seem to wriggle just
as the eel does to us. For everybody moving differently both from
this observer and ourselves, both the eel and the rod would seem to
wriggle. And there is no saying that one observer is right and another
wrong. In such matters, what is seen does not belong solely to the
physical process observed, but also to the standpoint of the observer.
Measurements of distances and times do not directly reveal properties
of the things measured, but relations of the things to the measurer.
What observation can tell us about the physical world is therefore more
abstract than we have hitherto believed.
It is important to realize that geometry, as taught in schools since
Greek times, ceases to exist as a separate science, and becomes merged
in physics. The two fundamental notions in elementary geometry were
the straight line and the circle. What appears to you as a straight
road, whose parts all exist now, may appear to another observer to
be like the flight of a rocket, some kind of curve whose parts come
into existence successively. The circle depends upon measurement of
distances, since it consists of all the points at a given distance
from its center. And measurement of distances, as we have seen, is
a subjective affair, depending upon the way in which the observer
is moving. The failure of the circle to have objective validity was
demonstrated by the Michelson-Morley experiment, and is thus, in a
sense, the starting point of the whole theory of relativity. Rigid
bodies, which we need for measurement, are only rigid for certain
observers; for others, they will be constantly changing all their
dimensions. It is only our obstinately earth-bound imagination that
makes us suppose a geometry separate from physics to be possible.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account