III. There were twentie five noble-men, and gentle-men voters without commission from the Kirk. Ma. _William Struthers_ voted for the Presbyterie of _Edinburgh_, yet had no commission there-from. The commission being given by that Presbyterie to other three, as the said Commission registrar in the books of the Presbytery beareth. And whereas there should be but one Commissioner from every burgh, except _Edinburgh_, to the Assembly; at this pretended Assembly, there were two Commissioners from _Glasgow_, two from _Cowper_, two from St. _Andrews_: whereas there were no ruling Elders having commission from their Presbyteries at that Assembly. IV. When the acts of that pretended assembly were written, the Bishop of St. _Andrews_ with his own hand did interline, adde, change, vitiate, direct to be extracted or not extracted, as he pleased: as the scrolls themselves seen, doe show; wherefore the Clerk did not registrat the acts of that Assembly, in the books of Assemblies, as may be easily seen by the blank in the register left for them remaining unfilled. _The nullitie of the pretended Assembly at_ Saint Andrews, 1617. I. There is no mention of it in the register of the Assemblies, and so no warrand for their commissions, their Moderatour or Clerk. II. The indiction of it was so unformall, that as the scroll declareth, a great part of the Commissioners from Synods, Burrows, and gentle-men, would not be present. III. The Kings Majestie in his letter to _Perths_ Assembly, acknowledged it was but a meeting, wherein disgrace was offered to his Majestie. IV. The former corruptions of the foure preceding Assemblies had their confluence in this and the subsequent Assembly. _Reasons for annulling the pretended Assembly, holden at_ Perth, 1618. I. The Assembly was indicted but twentie dayes before the holding of it: and all parties requisit received not advertisement, as appeareth by their absence. The untimous indicting of it, is cleared by Presbyterie books. II. There was no election of the Moderatour, as was accustomed to be in lawfull Assemblies; The register cleareth this. III. No formall election of their new Clerk. IIII. There were five whole Dioces absent, viz. _Orknay_, _Cathnes_, _Rosse_, _Argyll_, and _Isles_: and many Presbyteries had no Commissioners there, as the register of that pretended Assembly beareth. V. There were nineteen noblemen and Barrons, eleven Bishops that had no Commission from the Kirk. Whereas the act for constitution of Assemblies, ordaineth every Burgh to have but one Commissioner, except _Edinburgh_, which may have two (Act at _Dundie_ 1597) yet in that pretended Assembly, _Perth_ had three Commissioners, _Dundie_, had two, _Glasgow_ had two, and _St. Andrews_ had two: Of the Burghes, there were there six absent: And for ruling Elders, there were none at all with commission from their Presbyteries. All these things are cleared by the records of that pretended Assemblie.