The American novel to-day : $b A social and psychological studyMichaud, Régis
History
The American novel to-day : $b A social and psychological study
Michaud, Régis
American fiction -- History and criticism; Psychological fiction, American -- History and criticism; Social problems in literature
Crime, we might well say, constitutes an integral part of Dreiser’s
metaphysics. It occurs as a natural episode in the history of the
individual man asserting his will against society. The truth of the
aphorism that “might is right” cannot be proved without it. Crime and
the repressions which accompany it are the fatal results of the revolt
of temperament against its environment. After what we know of Dreiser’s
bio-chemical convictions, we may easily foresee that his philosophy
of crime and the criminal will give no part to responsibility. The
criminal, like the buccaneer of finance, of the “genius,” will be
a machine set in motion by blind and irresistible laws. Dreiser’s
determinism eliminates free will and along with it the criminal
himself. For this reason we must not expect the pathetic appeals
to conscience from him which are found in Victor Hugo, Dostoievski
and Tolstoi. Crime, according to Dreiser, has nothing to do with
conscience, since conscience does not exist, but it may have something
to do with science. In his ethical system there is no room for pity,
expiation and remorse. The days of “The Scarlet Letter” are gone. In
the light of bio-chemistry a criminal has no more or less importance
than a rattlesnake, a shark or the microbe of cancer. This determinism
in regard to crime was arraigned forty years ago in M. Paul Bourget’s
“The Disciple,” and it was cynically illustrated by Julien Sorel in
Stendhal’s “Le rouge et le noir.” Clyde Griffiths, like Robert Greslou
in “The Disciple,” has placed himself beyond evil and good. Let us hear
from Theodore Dreiser himself the story of Clyde Griffiths. It will
save many readers the trouble of plodding tediously along in the morass
of the most instructive and also the most monotonous book ever written
by the novelist.
Clyde Griffiths is the son of more or less abnormal parents. His
father and mother are religious fanatics. Clyde is ambitious and
dreams of a bright future. He begins as a bell boy of a hotel in
Kansas City. An uncle of his, a wealthy manufacturer, gives him a
start. He falls in love with the girl Roberta. He has a bio-chemical
idyll with her. Just at the moment that she becomes pregnant he finds
a new and more promising affinity in the person of a rich heiress.
The world is his if he marries her. But there is Roberta and her
trouble. What will Griffiths do with her? He deliberately plans to
get rid of her. He takes her to a pond and drowns her. He is caught,
tried, convicted and sent to the electric chair. _The Inevitable
Equation_ acts as mathematically and objectively in his case as a
guillotine. Bio-chemical predestination leaves no hope from the start.
The presentation of the case, the climax, the anticlimax, and the
_dénouement_ follow each other as the conclusions of a theorem. Nothing
is left to chance, providence or imagination. Griffiths acts thus and
thus, he wants this and this, and he gets what he deserves.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account