The American Quarterly Review, No. 18, June 1831 (Vol 9)Various
History
The American Quarterly Review, No. 18, June 1831 (Vol 9)
Various
Intellectual life -- Periodicals; United States -- Intellectual life -- 19th century -- Periodicals
"Against this liberal discipline," he remarks, "the example
of the Virginia university has very erroneously been alleged
by way of disapprobation, or as a failure: it affords no
proof of that kind. The erroneous system of collegiate life
has been preserved in it. The locality is insulated, and the
constant sameness of the company, of fellow-students only,
produces the bad results of tedious and too close influence
between the student, even with the professors. Besides that,
the architect of that building, the well informed,
philosophical, and amiable Jefferson, died before it was
finished; for the construction of such an institution is not
finished, with the walls that enclose its lecture rooms, or
the dwellings; the organization can only be the result of
several years actual activity of the institution,
particularly when the plan is novel in the place where it is
established. To this is still to be added, that the
professors appointed there, were all accustomed to the
collegiate life, and therefore not likely of such
dispositions as to be proper secundents to the liberal plans
of the original founder." P. 265.
Without pointing out the numerous minor errors that pervade this
paragraph, we may remark, that Mr. Hasler is manifestly uninformed
regarding the condition of the institution to which he alludes. We have
every reason for believing, that the discipline of the University of
Virginia, is equal to that which prevails in any institution of the
Union. The evils of bad discipline, occasioned by the want of sufficient
and efficient rules, were speedily experienced there. The objections
felt by the board of visiters to over-legislation, led to an opposite
error; whilst undue dependence was placed upon the effect that might be
produced from the participation of the students themselves in the
judicial power. Accordingly, we find, from the supplement to the printed
enactments, that it became necessary to tighten the reins of authority
during the very first session.
It has often been remarked, that owing to the feeble domestic discipline
which ordinarily prevails in the United States, the youth, particularly
of the southern parts of the Union, require a different mode of
management from those of other countries. There does not appear to be
the slightest foundation for this vulgar error. Young men, as well as
adults, are much alike over the whole civilized globe; and if it be
found that mild measures are ineffectual, recourse must be had to more
severe every where: and in all cases, the laws, where needed, must be
executed temperately, unhesitatingly, and firmly.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account