The atom and the Bohr theory of its structure : $b an elementary presentationHolst, Helge
Science
The atom and the Bohr theory of its structure : $b an elementary presentation
Holst, Helge
Atomic theory
But this
could not possibly take place, if the space from 6 to 5, which must
be traversed _en route_ to 4, is tuned for a lower note. The
same consideration applies to the hydrogen atom. Naturally it is not
impossible to continue the effort to illustrate the matter in some
concrete manner (one might, for example, imagine separate channels each
with its own particular tuning between the same two discs). But in all
these attempts the situation must become more and more complicated
rather than more simple.
On the whole it is very difficult to understand how a hydrogen atom,
where the electron makes a transition from orbit 6 to orbit 4, can
during the entire transition emit a radiation with a frequency
different from that when the electron goes from orbit 6 to orbit 5.
Although it seems as if the two electrons in making the transition are
at first under identical conditions, still, nevertheless, the one which
is going to orbit 4 emits from the first a radiation different from
that emitted by the one going to orbit 5. Even from the very beginning
the electron seems to arrange its conduct according to the goal of its
motion and also according to future events. But such a gift is wont to
be the privilege of thinking beings that can anticipate certain future
occurrences. The inanimate objects of physics should observe causal
laws in a more direct manner, _i.e._, allow their conduct to be
determined by their previous states and the contemporaneous influences
on them.
There is a difficulty of a similar nature in the fact that from the
same stationary orbit the electron sometimes starts for a single jump,
another time for a double jump, and so on. From certain considerations
it is often possible to propound laws for the probability of the
different jumps, so that for a great quantity of atoms it is possible
to calculate the strengths (intensities) of the corresponding spectral
lines. But we can no more give the reason why one given electron at a
given time determines to make a double jump while another decides to
make a single jump or not to jump at all, than we can say why a certain
radium nucleus among many explodes at a given moment (cf. p. 102). This
similarity between the occurrence of radiation processes on the Bohr
theory and of the radioactive processes has especially been emphasized
by Einstein.
It must, by no means, be said that the causal laws do not hold for the
atomic processes, but the hints given here indicate how difficult it
will be to reach an understanding—in the usual sense—of these processes
and consequently of the processes of physics in general. There is much
that might indicate that, on the whole, it is impossible to obtain a
consistent picture of atomic processes in space and time with the help
of the motions of the nuclei and the electrons and the variations in
the state of the ether, and with the application of such fundamental
conceptions of physics as mass, electric charge and energy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account