The Barbarity of Circumcision as a Remedy for Congenital AbnormalitySnow, Herbert
Philosophy
The Barbarity of Circumcision as a Remedy for Congenital Abnormality
Snow, Herbert
Circumcision; Penis -- Abnormalities
Although less severe measures have been from time to time brought
forward and advocated, the operation of circumcision is, to all intents
and purposes, the only procedure in general use for remedying congenital
phimosis; and as the latter is very common, so also is the performance
of this ancient sacrificial rite among that large majority of the
population who are otherwise in no way committed to it. There is a
simplicity and thoroughness about the little amputation which may
perhaps commend it to the surgical mind; and there are unquestionably
certain superficial advantages of a hygienic nature about the patient's
subsequent condition; though it may be doubted whether these are by any
means so considerable as has been made to appear.
However this may be, it goes without saying that no other curative
proceeding has so far met with any wide favour in the medical
profession; and, if one may judge from their published opinions, the
leading exponents of medical practice and opinion, in this country at
least, are so pleased with circumcision and its results that they would
willingly see the Mosaic Laws in this particular extended to the whole
Christian population, whether affected by phimosis or not. Witness Mr.
Jonathan Hutchinson:
It is surely not needful to seek any recondite motive for the
origin of the practice of circumcision. No one who has seen the
superior cleanliness of a Hebrew penis can have avoided a very
strong impression in favour of the removal of the foreskin. It
constitutes a harbour for filth, and is a constant source of
irritation. It conduces to masturbation, and adds to the
difficulties of sexual continence. It increases the risk of
syphilis in early life, and of cancer in the aged. I have never
seen cancer of the penis in a Jew, and chancres are
rare.--_Archives of Surgery._
Arguments by this distinguished surgeon, in favour of extension of the
custom as a matter of ordinary routine to every male Gentile, are to be
found in the _Medical Times and Gazette_, December 1, 1855; together
with a reference to previous utterances in an identical sense.
Erichsen (_Surgery_, Ninth Edition, 1888, vol. ii. p. 1188) says:
Every child who has a congenital phimosis ought to be circumcised;
and even those who, without having phimosis, have an abnormally
long and lax prepuce, would be improved greatly in cleanliness,
health, and morals by being subjected to the same operation. It
would be well if the custom of Eastern nations, whether it be
regarded as a religious rite or only as a time-honoured observance,
were introduced amongst us.
In Holmes's _System of Surgery_, 1883, we read:
Circumcision is the operation required in children; and it is best
adapted for adults also when the skin is redundant, and the margins
of the preputial opening are thickened.
Mr. W. H. Jacobson (_Operations of Surgery_, 1889) says:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account