The Barbarity of Circumcision as a Remedy for Congenital AbnormalitySnow, Herbert
Philosophy
The Barbarity of Circumcision as a Remedy for Congenital Abnormality
Snow, Herbert
Circumcision; Penis -- Abnormalities
In performing circumcision many surgeons hold the clamp or dressing
forceps which protect the glans inclined obliquely downwards and
forwards, so as to leave a portion of the prepuce in the neighbourhood
of the frænum unremoved. As one of the main advantages claimed for the
operation is the prevention of future infection by retention of morbid
material in the preputial folds, such a practice would seem to indicate
a lurking disbelief in the validity of this pretension. If it be
reasonable and right to excise the structure on these grounds, and if
that proceeding be attended by such salutary effects; it is only logical
not to do things by halves, but to make the excision as complete as
possible. Thus Liston made his section near the frænum, 'so as to retain
the skin on the glans, which is of advantage.' The use of the _elastic
ligature_, and of the _écraseurs_, both ordinary and galvanic, for the
performance of circumcision, are cruel and fantastic modes of effecting
that object, which hardly need any expression of condemnation; and which
it is difficult to believe can ever have been seriously advocated. Keyes
(_Diseases of the Urinary Organs_, 1888), after breaking up adhesions
with an oiled probe, marks an aniline line around the foreskin, and
amputates the skin, &c., in front of this mark; thus previously
estimating the amount of tissue to be removed.[13]
For operations involving the amputation of the whole, or nearly the
whole prepuce, the following advantages are claimed:--
(_a_) Greatly enhanced local cleanliness throughout after-life.
(_b_) Greater chastity; and the preclusion of immoral personal habits.
(_c_) A smaller liability to venereal contagion in after-life.
(_d_) A diminished proneness to eventual cancerous disease.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account