Difficult problems are not solved by fleeing from or by concealing
them; and yet many physicians, many philosophers attempt to solve the
most burning questions of modern society after the manner of a child who
by closing his eyes believes that he is fleeing from the dog that
threatens him. To Dr. Monlau in Spain and Dr. Bergeret in France, who
thought that they would be able to save society by abolishing
prostitution, I replied in a few words which I wish to save from the
shipwreck of the newspapers in order to gather them in the shadow of
this book:
"I have never wondered at finding philosophers who study man in
Fichte or in Kant without having ever touched his palpitating body,
or examined any of his fibers with the microscope; who advise the
legislator to destroy in the social organism, with iron and fire,
that livid and cancerous spot called prostitution; neither have I
given the alarm or extolled it as a miracle when I heard the
_auto-da-fé_ invoked against the houses of ill fame by moralists
who have had the rare fortune of having been born without the sixth
sense, or the still rarer merit of smothering it with the
extinguisher of an iron will. But when I hear these intolerant
cries from the mouth of a physician, I shake my head diffidently,
and with a compassionate voice I ask myself: 'Is he really a
physician? Has this moralist actually seen a man in convulsive
delirium and cut into his cold and rigid flesh on the chilly marble
slab of the anatomical cabinet? He who hurls the anathema at
prostitution, is he really the physician who should act as a kind
link between the legislator, who in man sees only a defendant to
punish, and the philanthropist, who in him considers only an
unhappy creature to heal and help?'
"These and other questions I addressed to the illustrious Spanish
physician Monlau when he proposed to his government the absolute
suppression of the houses of ill fame; and then I had the pleasure
of seeing my poor words printed in the progressive Spanish medical
journals. Now I make the same reproach to Dr. Bergeret, who, in
one of his memoirs on prostitution in the country places and small
towns of France, went so far as to fling the anathema against that
caustic wound which civilization has opened in the diseased flesh
of the modern social organism; and I, with a sad air, repeat to the
French physician a melancholy: '_Tu quoque, fili mi_?'
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account